celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Native nations and islands / Nevada held Spirit Cave Man for decades against his tribe, a judge called it arbitrary, and…
Case file s1127 · Native nations and islands · 8600 BCE
8600 BCE
Spirit Cave Mummy: Remains of the Spirit Cave mummy still in the wrapping and cloth it was buried in. Spirit Cave is located in Fallon, Nevada. Discovered in 1940. This image was p
Spirit Cave Mummy. Photograph by Chip Clark, Smithsonian. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
c. 8600 BC (about 10,600 years ago)
Place
Spirit Cave, near Fallon, Nevada, USA
Field
ancestral remains; repatriation
Legal tradition
NAGPRA (1990) and the 2010 rule on culturally unidentifiable remains
Historical event
Fallon Paiute-Shoshone Tribe v. Bureau of Land Management, 2006

Nevada held Spirit Cave Man for decades against his tribe, a judge called it arbitrary, and the tribe agreed to DNA to prove he was theirs

In 1940 Georgia and Sydney Wheeler found a man of about 40 in Spirit Cave, wrapped in a rabbit-skin blanket and reed mats and wearing moccasins. They thought he was 1,500 to 2,000 years old. Radiocarbon dating in the 1990s gave about 10,600 years, making him North America's oldest mummy. The Fallon Paiute-Shoshone Tribe, whose reservation is nearby, claimed him as an ancestor for reburial. In 2000 the Bureau of Land Management refused. The tribe sued, and in 2006 a federal judge ruled the refusal "arbitrary and capricious." The tribe had opposed genetic testing. It then agreed, and in October 2015 geneticist Eske Willerslev took bone and tooth samples. Willerslev said he told the tribe there would be no testing without its permission. The genome showed the man was closer to Native Americans than to any other group. The tribe said the result confirmed its oral tradition and that its experience of scientists had been "mostly negative." On 18 November 2016 the Bureau transferred him and his burial goods to the tribe. Anthropologist Douglas Jantz, who co-led an earlier study of the skull, called it "a sad day for science." The tribe reburied him privately in 2018†.

What the law took from it

The heirs won custody of the body only after giving the science that had been used to deny them.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Nevada held Spirit Cave Man for decades against his tribe, a judge called it arbitrary, and the tribe agreed to DNA to prove he was theirs,” story s1127, https://www.celebrity.estate/spirit-cave-man-8600-bc, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Anna Nicole Smith: Anna Nicole Smith2007 · Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino, Hollywood, Florida, UAnna Nicole Smith's body went to her 5-month-old daughter's guardian after a Florida judge wept through the ruling, and DNA named the girl's fatherShared: secret children and false heirs; bodies, bones and burials; also North AmericaAnna Nicole Smith gave birth to a daughter, Dannielynn, in the Bahamas on 7 September 2006. Three days later her son Daniel, 20, died in her hospital room. The Bahamian birth certificate named her lawyer and companion Howard K.cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov and 7 moreJuan Gabriel: Juan Gabriel in 1985 (cropped)2016 · Santa Monica, CaliforniaJuan Gabriel left everything to one son, and a man claiming to be another son asked a court for part of his remainsShared: secret children and false heirs; bodies, bones and burials; also North AmericaJuan Gabriel, born Alberto Aguilera Valadez, wrote more than 1,800 songs. He died of a heart attack in Santa Monica at 66. His son Iván Aguilera was named sole beneficiary.loeb.com and 2 moreRobert Johnson1938 · near Greenwood, MississippiRobert Johnson died in 1938 with nothing, and a Mississippi court found his heir 62 years laterShared: secret children and false heirs; bodies, bones and burials; also North AmericaRobert Johnson recorded 29 songs in 1936 and 1937 and died at 27, owning almost nothing. Three graves in Mississippi claim his body.The Seattle Times and 3 moreHarry Houdini: Harry Houdini1926 · Detroit, MichiganHoudini's great-nephew and two authors announced a 2007 plan to exhume his body to test for poisonShared: secret children and false heirs; bodies, bones and burials; also North AmericaHarry Houdini died at 52 on 31 October 1926. The accepted account is that a punch to the stomach in Montreal on 22 October ruptured his appendix, causing peritonitis. No autopsy was performed.wildabouthoudini.com and 2 moreAlbert Einstein: Albert Einstein Head cleaned1955 · Princeton, New Jersey, USAEinstein gave his Nobel money to his first wife and asked to be cremated in secret, and the pathologist kept his brain for decadesShared: secret children and false heirs; bodies, bones and burials; also North AmericaOn 12 June 1918 Albert Einstein signed an agreement with his first wife, Mileva Marić.nationalgeographic.com and 3 moreLaurel Hill Cemetery Advertisement (1904): Laurel Hill Cemetery Advertisement (1904) From "Philadelphia: The Birthplace of the Nation, The Pivot of Industry, The City of Homes" by 1930 · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USAHenrietta Garrett died in 1930 with $17 million and no will; more than 25,000 people claimed to be her kin, ten went to jail, and three cousins she never met inheritedShared: secret children and false heirs; bodies, bones and burials; also North AmericaHenrietta Garrett was a childless widow who lived almost as a hermit in Philadelphia. She died on 16 November 1930 with no will and a residuary estate of about $17 million.legalgenealogist.com and 2 more