celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Hollywood and TV / Brittany Murphy's father sued the coroner for her hair samples, then said a lab found heavy…
Case file s1689 · Hollywood and TV · 2009
2009
Brittany Murphy: Brittany Murphy
Brittany Murphy. Rob & Jules. CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
20 December 2009
Place
Hollywood Hills, Los Angeles, California, USA
Field
actress · Film and television on the timeline
Legal tradition
US common law (California coroner law; legal malpractice) · Common law
Historical event
The deaths of Brittany Murphy and Simon Monjack in the same Hollywood Hills house, 2009 and 2010
Religion
Brittany Murphy: Other Christian (recorded as Christianity on Wikidata)

Brittany Murphy's father sued the coroner for her hair samples, then said a lab found heavy metals; her mother called it a smear

Brittany Murphy collapsed at the Hollywood Hills house she shared with her husband, Simon Monjack, and her mother, Sharon Murphy, and died at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center on 20 December 2009, aged 32. Her death certificate listed her father as "unknown." On 25 February 2010 the Los Angeles County coroner ruled the death accidental, caused by pneumonia, with anemia and multiple drug intoxication as factors. Monjack died in the same house on 23 May 2010, of acute pneumonia and anemia. In April 2011, after repeated appeals, county officials added her father, Angelo Bertolotti, to the death certificate. On 19 December 2011 Sharon Murphy sued the lawyers who had represented her in a settlement with the house's builders, alleging they had not told her that settling waived her right to sue for wrongful death; she settled that suit on 7 February 2013. On 11 January 2012 Bertolotti, acting as his own lawyer, sued the coroner and the Los Angeles Police Department in Los Angeles Superior Court, alleging neither had tested her hair for "poisons, toxins or heavy metals." A judge dismissed the suit on 24 July 2012 after he failed to appear in court a second time. After a second unsuccessful suit, the coroner agreed in 2013 to send hair and tissue samples to a laboratory of his choice once he proved he was her father. On 18 November 2013 he released a private laboratory report finding "high levels of heavy metals" and said she and Monjack had been poisoned. Sharon Murphy called the claim "a smear." In April 2016 the coroner's office said it had no immediate plans to reopen the inquiry.

What the law took from it

A settlement with one party can waive the heirs' wrongful-death claims, so heirs need to know what a release covers before they sign it.

Family version vs. the record

Angelo Bertolotti said a private laboratory's hair test showed poisoning ( The coroner ruled the death accidental, from pneumonia with anemia and drug intoxication ( and a judge dismissed his suit when he missed a second court date (

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Brittany Murphy's father sued the coroner for her hair samples, then said a lab found heavy metals; her mother called it a smear,” story s1689, https://www.celebrity.estate/brittany-murphy-2009, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Robin Williams 2011a (2): Happy Feet Two Australian premiere with Robin Williams and George Miller at Entertainment Quarter in Sydney, Australia2014 · Paradise Cay, Tiburon, California, USARobin Williams's widow and three children fought in a San Francisco court over his belongings, and the children got more than 85 watchesShared: also Hollywood and TV; 5 years apart; also North AmericaRobin Williams died at his home in Paradise Cay, near Tiburon, California, on 11 August 2014, aged 63. His death was ruled a suicide. He had been diagnosed with Parkinson's disease, and the autopsy found diffuse Lewy body dementia.journals.law.harvard.edu and 12 moreHeath Ledger: Heath Ledger (2)2008 · 421 Broome Street, ManhattanHeath Ledger's will was written before his daughter was born and left her nothingShared: also Hollywood and TV; 1 year apart; also North AmericaHeath Ledger died in his Manhattan apartment at 28 from an accidental overdose of six prescription drugs. His three-page will, signed in 2003, left everything to his parents, Kim and Sally, and his three sisters.archive.triblive.com and 3 moreElizabeth Taylor: Taylor, Elizabeth posed2011 · Los Angeles, CaliforniaElizabeth Taylor's jewelry sold for $137,235,575 at Christie's in December 2011, the most ever paid for a jewelry collection, with the proceeds going to her foundationShared: also Hollywood and TV; 2 years apart; also North AmericaElizabeth Taylor died on 23 March 2011. Christie's sold her jewelry in New York on 13 and 14 December 2011. The evening sale on 13 December brought $115.9 million.guinnessworldrecords.com and 2 moreMarlon Brando: Marlon Brando publicity for One-Eyed Jacks2004 · Los Angeles, CaliforniaMarlon Brando's $21.6 million will left out one child, and a son's girlfriend scattered part of his ashesShared: also Hollywood and TV; 5 years apart; also North AmericaMarlon Brando died at UCLA Medical Center on July 1, 2004, at 80. His will, signed on August 28, 2002, and filed on July 9, 2004, in Los Angeles County Superior Court, valued his estate at $21.6 million.Los Angeles Times and 1 morePhilip Seymour Hoffman: Philip Seymour Hoffman at the Paris premiere of "The Ides of March"2014 · New York CityPhilip Seymour Hoffman left an estimated $35 million to Mimi O'Donnell, whom he never married, and refused a trust for his three childrenShared: also Hollywood and TV; 5 years apart; also North AmericaPhilip Seymour Hoffman died of a drug overdose on 2 February 2014.foxnews.com and 3 moreAnne Heche: Anne Heche July 14, 2014 (3x4 cropped)2022 · Los Angeles, California, USAAnne Heche's ex said a 2011 email was her will, and the court gave her estate to her 20-year-old sonShared: also Hollywood and TV; 13 years apart; also North AmericaAnne Heche crashed her car into a Los Angeles house in August 2022 and died days later. She left no formal will. Her older son, Homer Laffoon, 20, petitioned to run the estate.etonline.com and 3 more