celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Cities / Sarah Althea Hill produced a marriage contract and a will from San Francisco's richest man,…
Case file s1545 · Cities · 1885
1885
The Shooting of Judge Terry - National Police Gazette 1889-08-31: The Shooting of Judge Terry. Scenes in and about the Lathrop, Cal., depot where Marshal Nagle killed the famous hu
The Shooting of Judge Terry - National Police Gazette 1889-08-31. Unknown artist. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
13 November 1885 (William Sharon)
Place
San Francisco, California, USA
Field
mining, banking and hotels (Palace Hotel, Grand Hotel) · Business and finance on the timeline
Legal tradition
California marriage and divorce law; US federal circuit court · Common law
Historical event
In re Neagle (US Supreme Court, 1890)

Sarah Althea Hill produced a marriage contract and a will from San Francisco's richest man, federal judges ruled them forged, and her husband was shot dead attacking a Supreme Court justice

William Sharon was a US senator and the richest man in San Francisco. He owned the Palace Hotel and the Grand Hotel. In 1880 he began an affair with Sarah Althea Hill, paid her $500 a month and gave her a room at the Grand. In 1881 he ended it and had her evicted. On 8 September 1883 she had him arrested for adultery. She then sued for divorce in the San Francisco superior court, producing a secret marriage contract dated August 1880. Sharon sued in federal circuit court, claiming Nevada citizenship, to have the contract declared a forgery. In December 1884 state Judge Jeremiah Sullivan declared her Sharon's wife and awarded alimony. Sharon died in November 1885, and Hill produced a handwritten will leaving her his estate. A federal decree of January 1886 found the contract fraudulent and void. She married her lawyer, David Terry. In September 1888, as Justice Stephen Field read a ruling for Sharon's executor, she shouted accusations at him; Terry struck a marshal and reached for a bowie knife, and both went to jail for contempt. In July 1889 the California Supreme Court ruled the marriage invalid. On 14 August 1889, at Lathrop, Terry struck Field, and Deputy Marshal David Neagle shot him dead. The Supreme Court held Neagle immune from state prosecution. Sharon's son-in-law, Francis Newlands, ran the estate and moved the heirs to Nevada to keep federal protection. Hill was committed to the Stockton asylum in 1892 and died in 1937.

What the law took from it

Documents that appear only after a quarrel or a death invite a forgery trial; Sharon's executors kept the estate by keeping the case in federal court.

Record vs. record

Sharon's death is dated 13 November 1885 (Wikipedia) and 14 November 1885 (Stanford's Newlands project); the secret marriage is dated 20 August 1880 (Wikipedia) and 8 August 1880 (Stanford):

Sources
  1. Cornell Law School, LIICourt record
  2. newlands.stanford.eduScholarship
  3. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Sarah Althea Hill produced a marriage contract and a will from San Francisco's richest man, federal judges ruled them forged, and her husband was shot dead attacking a Supreme Court justice,” story s1545, https://www.celebrity.estate/sarah-althea-hill-1885, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Rice University - William Marsh Rice statue1900 · New York CityA lawyer and a valet killed William Marsh Rice in 1900 to take the fortune he left to found Rice InstituteShared: secret children and false heirs; forged and faked wills; 15 years apart; also North AmericaRice made his money in Texas land, cotton, lumber and railroads. The 1860 census valued his property at $750,000 and ranked him the richest man in Houston. From 1882 his wills directed most of his estate to an institute in Houston.chroniclingamerica.loc.gov and 2 moreThe Japanese Tea Garden, located inside Golden Gate Park, San Francisco, California LCCN2013630140: Title: The Japanese Tea Garden, located inside Golden Gate Park, San Francisco, 1925 · Golden Gate Park, San Francisco, California, USAThe Hagiwara family kept San Francisco's Japanese Tea Garden for 47 years; the 1942 removal orders took it, and the city paid two survivors $5,000 each in 1983Shared: the same person; also North AmericaThe garden began as an exhibit at the 1894 California Midwinter International Exposition. Makoto Hagiwara, who had come to San Francisco in 1878, paid to build it and was its caretaker from 1895.goldengatepark.substack.com and 3 moreAndrew Carnegie: Andrew Carnegie, by Theodore Marceau (cropped) (2)1907 · Ohio State Penitentiary, ColumbusCassie Chadwick said she was Andrew Carnegie's illegitimate daughter, borrowed against forged Carnegie notes, and broke an Ohio bankShared: secret children and false heirs; forged and faked wills; 22 years apart; also North AmericaElizabeth Bigley was born in Ontario in 1857. In 1889 she was convicted of forgery in Toledo and sentenced to nine and a half years. She was paroled in 1893.case.edu and 3 moreXXXTentacion: Xxxtentacion (cropped)2018 · Deerfield Beach, FloridaXXXTentacion was shot dead at 20, and his son was born seven months later outside his willShared: secret children and false heirs; murder and sudden death; also North AmericaJahseh Onfroy, the rapper XXXTentacion, was shot dead outside a motorcycle dealership in Deerfield Beach, aged 20. The killers took $50,000 from him.nbcmiami.com and 2 moreJerzy Kosiński: Jerzy Kosiński (by Eric Koch, 1969)1991 · New York CityJerzy Kosiński was accused of plagiarism and ghostwriting in 1982 and killed himself in 1991 with a plastic bag over his headShared: secret children and false heirs; murder and sudden death; also North AmericaKosiński's The Painted Bird (1965) was banned in Poland until 1989.Encyclopaedia Britannica and 3 moreZhang Xueliang: Chang Shueliang2001 · HonoluluZhang Xueliang inherited his murdered father's Manchurian army in 1928 and spent more than 50 years in detentionShared: secret children and false heirs; murder and sudden death; also North AmericaOn 4 June 1928 a bomb planted by Col. Komoto Daisaku of Japan's Kwantung Army hit warlord Zhang Zuolin's train at Huanggutun near Shenyang. Zhang died a few hours later, and his death was kept secret for more than two weeks.library.columbia.edu and 4 more