celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / North America / James Addison Reavis forged a Spanish barony covering 12 million acres of Arizona,…
Case file s1568 · North America · 1874
1874
James Addison Reavis in prison clothes: James Addison Reavis with imprisoned at Santa Fe, New Mexico Territory
James Addison Reavis in prison clothes. Land of Sunshine Publishing Co.. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
1874 (George M. Willing, from whom Reavis acquired the claim); Reavis died in 1914
Place
Phoenix, Arizona, USA
Field
land-grant claims · Royalty and nobility on the timeline
Legal tradition
Spanish and Mexican land-grant law under the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo; US Court of Private Land Claims · Common law · Civil law
Historical event
Settlement of Arizona Territory after the Gadsden Purchase

James Addison Reavis forged a Spanish barony covering 12 million acres of Arizona, presented a ranch girl as its heiress, and went to prison

George M. Willing, a prospector, said he had bought a Spanish land grant from a man named Miguel Peralta. In 1874 Willing was found dead the morning after he went to Prescott to file it. James Addison Reavis obtained Willing's interest in 1881 and arrived in Arizona in 1882. He collected genuine documents and planted forged ones in archives in Guadalajara and Madrid to create a line of Peralta barons descending from a 1748 grant. He claimed more than 12 million acres of Arizona and New Mexico, from Phoenix to Silver City. The Southern Pacific Railroad paid him $50,000 for a right of way, and the owners of the Silver King mine paid $25,000. He took a young woman with no birth record from a California ranch, made her his ward, and presented her as Sofia Loreto Micaela, last of the Peraltas and Baroness of Arizona. Arizona Highways names her as Sophia Treadway, a servant. Surveyor General Royal Johnson found inconsistencies, and an investigator in Spain found forged pages inserted in the Madrid archives. In June 1895 the claim and Reavis's $10 million suit were tried at Santa Fe and rejected in full. He was convicted of conspiracy to defraud, sentenced to two years in a federal penitentiary and fined $5,000. Sofia divorced him for non-support and went to Denver with their twins. Reavis died in 1914.

What the law took from it

A title built from archive papers fails when someone checks the archive.

Record vs. record

The claim is given as more than 12 million acres (Online Archive of California), nearly 11 million acres (Arizona Highways) and 18,600 square miles (Saturday Evening Post):

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “James Addison Reavis forged a Spanish barony covering 12 million acres of Arizona, presented a ranch girl as its heiress, and went to prison,” story s1568, https://www.celebrity.estate/james-addison-reavis-1874, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Edgar Allan Poe: Edgar Allan Poe, circa 1849, restored, squared off1849 · Baltimore, MarylandEdgar Allan Poe's self-appointed literary executor was his enemy, who wrote his obituary under a false name and rewrote his lettersShared: forged and faked wills; 25 years apart; also North AmericaPoe and the editor Rufus Wilmot Griswold had feuded for years. Two days after Poe died, Griswold published an obituary under the pen name "Ludwig" in the New York Tribune. It attacked Poe's character.bpl.org and 3 moreThe Shooting of Judge Terry - National Police Gazette 1889-08-31: The Shooting of Judge Terry. Scenes in and about the Lathrop, Cal., depot where Marshal Nagle killed the famous hu1885 · San Francisco, California, USASarah Althea Hill produced a marriage contract and a will from San Francisco's richest man, federal judges ruled them forged, and her husband was shot dead attacking a Supreme Court justiceShared: forged and faked wills; 11 years apart; also North AmericaWilliam Sharon was a US senator and the richest man in San Francisco. He owned the Palace Hotel and the Grand Hotel. In 1880 he began an affair with Sarah Althea Hill, paid her $500 a month and gave her a room at the Grand.Cornell Law School, LII and 2 moreRice University - William Marsh Rice statue1900 · New York CityA lawyer and a valet killed William Marsh Rice in 1900 to take the fortune he left to found Rice InstituteShared: forged and faked wills; 26 years apart; also North AmericaRice made his money in Texas land, cotton, lumber and railroads. The 1860 census valued his property at $750,000 and ranked him the richest man in Houston. From 1882 his wills directed most of his estate to an institute in Houston.chroniclingamerica.loc.gov and 2 moreAndrew Carnegie: Andrew Carnegie, by Theodore Marceau (cropped) (2)1907 · Ohio State Penitentiary, ColumbusCassie Chadwick said she was Andrew Carnegie's illegitimate daughter, borrowed against forged Carnegie notes, and broke an Ohio bankShared: forged and faked wills; same era, industry and empire; also North AmericaElizabeth Bigley was born in Ontario in 1857. In 1889 she was convicted of forgery in Toledo and sentenced to nine and a half years. She was paroled in 1893.case.edu and 3 moreLisa Marie Presley: Lisa Marie Presley (cropped)2023 · Graceland, Memphis, Tennessee, USALisa Marie Presley's trust was told it owed $3.8 million on Graceland, and the Missouri woman who forged the loan got 57 months in prisonShared: forged and faked wills; also North AmericaLisa Marie Presley died on 12 January 2023. Graceland, which she owned, was held in her trust, and her daughter Riley Keough became sole trustee that year.justice.gov and 5 moreBob Marley: Bob Marley circa 1976 (cropped)1981 · Cedars of Lebanon Hospital, MiamiBob Marley died without a will, and his widow forged his signature to move his companies into her nameShared: forged and faked wills; also North AmericaBob Marley died of cancer at 36. He left no will, a wife, Rita, and 11 children by several women. Under Jamaican intestacy law Rita received 10 percent outright and a life interest in 45 percent; the 11 children shared the rest.FindLaw Caselaw and 3 more