celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Foundations / A 1997 essay called "Broken Trust" led a Hawaii court to remove the Bishop Estate trustees,…
Case file s94 · Foundations · 1884
1884
Kamehameha Schools: First Graduating Class of the Kamehameha School for Boys, 1891
Kamehameha Schools. Kamehameha Schools Archives. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
16 October 1884 (Bernice Pauahi Bishop)
Place
Honolulu, Kingdom of Hawaii · Pacific islands
Field
Hawaiian royalty, landowner · Royalty and nobility on the timeline
Legal tradition
Hawaii trust law (probate court)
Historical event
Great Mahele land division of 1848; Native Hawaiian education

A 1997 essay called "Broken Trust" led a Hawaii court to remove the Bishop Estate trustees, who were paid up to $900,000 a year

Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, last of the Kamehameha line, left about 375,000 acres in trust in her 1883 will to run schools for Hawaiian children. Justices of the Hawaii Supreme Court chose the trustees. Many were political insiders, and by 1997 each was paid $800,000 to $900,000 a year. On 9 August 1997 five community leaders, including retired judges Walter Heen and Samuel King and law professor Randall Roth, published "Broken Trust" in the Honolulu Star-Bulletin. They accused the trustees of self-dealing and micromanagement and asked for a state investigation. Governor Ben Cayetano ordered Attorney General Margery Bronster to investigate. On 10 September 1997 she reported that beneficiaries' rights "may be at substantial risk." She sought removal of trustees Lokelani Lindsey, Richard Wong and Henry Peters. On 6 May 1999, after a six-month trial, the probate court permanently removed Lindsey. The next day it temporarily removed Wong, Peters and Gerard Jervis; Oswald Stender resigned. The state Senate refused to reconfirm Bronster on 28 April 1999, 14 to 11. The IRS had threatened the trust's tax exemption†. The trust, renamed Kamehameha Schools, is Hawaii's largest private landowner†.

What the law took from it

When judges or politicians appoint charitable trustees, the trust can become patronage, and outside scrutiny by beneficiaries and the attorney general is what resets it.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “A 1997 essay called "Broken Trust" led a Hawaii court to remove the Bishop Estate trustees, who were paid up to $900,000 a year,” story s94, https://www.celebrity.estate/a-1997-essay-called-broken-trust-1884, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Jane Stanford: Portrait of Jane Stanford1905 · Moana Hotel, Honolulu, HawaiiJane Stanford, sole funder of Stanford University, died of strychnine in 1905 and the university president said it was natural causesShared: also Foundations; 21 years apart; also North AmericaLeland and Jane Stanford founded the university in 1885 in memory of their only child.Internet Archive and 2 moreRice University - William Marsh Rice statue1900 · New York CityA lawyer and a valet killed William Marsh Rice in 1900 to take the fortune he left to found Rice InstituteShared: also Foundations; 16 years apart; also North AmericaRice made his money in Texas land, cotton, lumber and railroads. The 1860 census valued his property at $750,000 and ranked him the richest man in Houston. From 1882 his wills directed most of his estate to an institute in Houston.chroniclingamerica.loc.gov and 2 moreStephen Girard: Stephen Girard by JR Lambdin1831 · PhiladelphiaStephen Girard left $7.5 million for "poor white male orphans", and courts fought over the word "white" until 1968Shared: also Foundations; same era, industry and empire; also North AmericaStephen Girard, a French-born merchant, opened Girard's Bank in 1812 and underwrote up to 95 percent of a federal war loan. He died in 1831 with an estate of about $7.5 million.Cornell Law School, LII and 3 moreElon Musk: Elon Musk - 54820081119 (3x4 cropped, Rule of thirds)2024 · Austin, TexasElon Musk gave his foundation $7.9 billion in Tesla stock in two years, and its filings show it paid out less than requiredShared: also Foundations; also North AmericaElon and Kimbal Musk set up the Musk Foundation in 2001 with about $2.1 million in eBay shares. Its board is Elon Musk and two employees of his family office, Jared Birchall and Matilda Simon, and it has no staff.Cornell Law School, LII and 2 moreBill Gates: Bill Gates at the European Commission - P067383-987995 (cropped) 52025 · Seattle, WashingtonBill Gates said in May 2025 the Gates Foundation will spend its endowment and close on 31 December 2045Shared: also Foundations; also North AmericaBill and Melinda Gates built the largest US private foundation, holding its assets in the Gates Foundation Trust.The New York Times and 3 moreMark Twain: Mark Twain by AF Bradley (cropped 2)1910 · Redding, ConnecticutMark Twain fired his secretary Isabel Lyon in 1909 and wrote 429 pages accusing her and her husband, a text kept private until 2015Shared: 26 years apart; also North AmericaIsabel Lyon became Twain's secretary in 1902. After his wife Olivia died in 1904 she moved into his house, paid allowances to his daughters Clara and Jean, and helped supervise the building of Stormfield.lynncullen.com and 1 more