celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Foundations / Stephen Girard left $7.5 million for "poor white male orphans", and courts fought over the…
Case file s72 · Foundations · 1831
1831
Stephen Girard: Stephen Girard by JR Lambdin
Stephen Girard. JR Lambdin, from a posthumous portrait by B. Otis. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
26 December 1831
Place
Philadelphia · United States
Field
merchant, banker · Business and finance on the timeline
Legal tradition
Pennsylvania common law and equity (charitable trusts) · Common law
Historical event
War of 1812 finance; the civil rights movement
Religion
Stephen Girard: Atheist and agnostic (recorded as atheism on Wikidata; American atheists on Wikipedia)

Stephen Girard left $7.5 million for "poor white male orphans", and courts fought over the word "white" until 1968

Stephen Girard, a French-born merchant, opened Girard's Bank in 1812 and underwrote up to 95 percent of a federal war loan. He died in 1831 with an estate of about $7.5 million. His will left most of it to the City of Philadelphia for a college to take "as many poor white male orphans, between the ages of six and ten years, as the said income shall be adequate to maintain." It barred any "ecclesiastic, missionary, or minister of any sect whatsoever" from holding any post there. His French relatives sued to break the charitable trust, with Daniel Webster as their counsel. In Vidal v. Girard's Executors (1844) the US Supreme Court upheld the will. The college opened on 1 January 1848. In 1957 the Supreme Court ruled that the city board running the trust was a state agency and could not turn away two Black boys. Pennsylvania's Orphans' Court then replaced the board with private trustees. Cecil B. Moore led protests from May 1965, and Martin Luther King Jr. spoke there that August. On 7 March 1968 the federal Third Circuit held that the swap was still state action, which "pushed the College right back into its old and ugly unconstitutional position." The first four Black students entered on 11 September 1968. Girls were admitted from 1984. In 2026 Girard's remains lie in Founder's Hall, the college runs as a full-scholarship boarding school, and the Girard Estate reported a net position of $440.6 million in 2022.

What the law took from it

A perpetual charitable trust outlives the values written into it, and courts will set aside conditions that collide with later law.

Family version vs. the record

The French heirs argued the trust was invalid; the Supreme Court upheld it in 1844.

Sources
  1. Cornell Law School, LIICourt record
  2. supreme.justia.comCourt record
  3. law.resource.orgCourt record
  4. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Stephen Girard left $7.5 million for "poor white male orphans", and courts fought over the word "white" until 1968,” story s72, https://www.celebrity.estate/stephen-girard-1831, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Elon Musk: Elon Musk - 54820081119 (3x4 cropped, Rule of thirds)2024 · Austin, TexasElon Musk gave his foundation $7.9 billion in Tesla stock in two years, and its filings show it paid out less than requiredShared: given away; also Foundations; also North AmericaElon and Kimbal Musk set up the Musk Foundation in 2001 with about $2.1 million in eBay shares. Its board is Elon Musk and two employees of his family office, Jared Birchall and Matilda Simon, and it has no staff.Cornell Law School, LII and 2 moreBill Gates: Bill Gates at the European Commission - P067383-987995 (cropped) 52025 · Seattle, WashingtonBill Gates said in May 2025 the Gates Foundation will spend its endowment and close on 31 December 2045Shared: given away; also Foundations; also North AmericaBill and Melinda Gates built the largest US private foundation, holding its assets in the Gates Foundation Trust.The New York Times and 3 morePaul Newman: Paul Newman - 19582008 · Westport, ConnecticutPaul Newman left his food company to a foundation run by his adviser, his daughter said the family was pushed out, and Congress changed the law for itShared: given away; also Foundations; also North AmericaIn 1982 Paul Newman and A.E. Hotchner started Newman's Own with $20,000 each, and all its after-tax profits went to charity.Cornell Law School, LII and 2 moreConrad Hilton: Conrad Hilton (croped)1979 · Santa Monica, CaliforniaConrad Hilton left his hotel shares to his foundation, and his son Barron spent 10 years in court winning them backShared: given away; also Foundations; also North AmericaConrad Hilton founded the Conrad N. Hilton Foundation in 1944 and made it the principal beneficiary of his estate. His will also gave his son Barron, chairman of Hilton Hotels, an option to buy the hotel stock.Los Angeles Times and 3 moreAI illustration: The New York State Supreme Court building on Centre Street, 20182018 · New York, New YorkNew York shut down the Donald J. Trump Foundation in 2018 and Trump paid $2 million to eight charitiesShared: given away; also Foundations; also North AmericaDonald Trump formed the foundation in 1988. During the 2016 campaign, Washington Post reporting raised questions about its spending.ag.ny.gov and 1 moreHenry Ford and Charlie the Elephant at Universal City 1916 021947 · Dearborn, MichiganThe Fords put 90% of Ford Motor into a foundation and kept the votes, and Henry Ford II quit its board in 1976Shared: given away; also Foundations; also North AmericaEdsel Ford and two executives chartered the Ford Foundation in Michigan on 15 January 1936. Henry Ford's will split his Ford Motor holdings into Class A nonvoting and Class B voting stock.Internet Archive and 3 more