celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Probate and trust law / A colonel took the trousers off the solicitor who wrote himself into a client's will, went…
Case file s1420 · Probate and trust law · 1947
1947
Map of United Kingdom, marked on the globe
Map of United Kingdom. Rob. CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
1947 (Kitty Wells)
Place
Brighton, England, UK (the solicitor's practice)
Field
private fortune · Military on the timeline
Legal tradition
English probate law; suspicious circumstances where the drafter of a will benefits from it · Common law
Historical event
Wintle v Nye [1959] 1 WLR 284, House of Lords

A colonel took the trousers off the solicitor who wrote himself into a client's will, went to prison, then beat him in the House of Lords without a lawyer

Kitty Wells died in 1947 with an estate of £115,000. Her will was drawn up by her solicitor, Frederick Nye, of Brighton, and named Nye as residuary beneficiary. The residue came to £44,000. Her cousin, Lieutenant-Colonel Alfred Wintle of the First Royal Dragoons, accused Nye of cheating the family and complained to the Law Society without result. Wintle lured Nye to a meeting under a false pretext, forced him to take off his trousers, photographed him in a newspaper hat and left him in the street. He kept the trousers as a trophy in his club. He was sentenced to six months in prison for the assault. He then took an assignment of a beneficiary's interest so that he could challenge the will. He lost before a judge and jury and lost 2 to 1 in the Court of Appeal. In the House of Lords he argued his own case for six days, helped by his former batman, Cedric Mays, who prepared the appeal books with him. He won unanimously, the first non-lawyer to do so in the House of Lords, and Nye was refused his costs. Viscount Simonds held that a will prepared by a stranger who benefits under it raises a suspicion that the person propounding it must remove. Nye was later struck off the roll of solicitors. The sources do not say who received the £44,000 in the end.

What the law took from it

A will drafted by the person who benefits from it starts under suspicion; an independent lawyer removes the doubt.

Sources
  1. alrc.gov.auGovernment record
  2. lawgazette.co.ukPress
  3. newlawjournal.co.ukPress

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “A colonel took the trousers off the solicitor who wrote himself into a client's will, went to prison, then beat him in the House of Lords without a lawyer,” story s1420, https://www.celebrity.estate/wintle-v-nye-1947, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Bundesverfassungsgericht - Karlsruhe: Bundesverfassungsgericht - Karlsruhe1994 · Cologne court district, North Rhine-Westphalia, GermanyA German mother disinherited the son who attacked her, he killed her a month later, and two courts still awarded him his compulsory shareShared: also Probate and trust law; same era, postwar; also EuropeA widow had two sons. In 1982 her will named one of them sole heir. The other son had a schizophrenic psychosis and lived with her in her house. He attacked her repeatedly.servat.unibe.ch and 3 moreJudy Garland: Judy Garland publicity photo1969 · Cadogan Lane, Belgravia, LondonJudy Garland's fifth husband buried her in New York; 48 years later her children moved her to HollywoodShared: 22 years apart; also EuropeJudy Garland died at 47 of an accidental barbiturate overdose, three months after marrying nightclub manager Mickey Deans.CBS News and 3 moreCharlie Chaplin: Charlie Chaplin portrait Getty 17394119521977 · Corsier-sur-Vevey, SwitzerlandTwo men stole Charlie Chaplin's coffin for ransom, and his widow refused to payShared: 30 years apart; also EuropeCharlie Chaplin moved to Switzerland after the United States revoked his re-entry permit in 1952. He died at home in Corsier-sur-Vevey on Christmas Day 1977, aged 88. He left more than $100 million to his widow, Oona.history.co.uk and 3 moreAgatha Christie: Agatha Christie in Nederland (detectiveschrijfster), bij aankomst op Schiphol me, Bestanddeelnr 916-8898 (cropped)1976 · Wallingford, EnglandAgatha Christie gave her grandson the rights to The Mousetrap as a child, and the company holding her estate was sold three timesShared: 29 years apart; also EuropeAgatha Christie gave her grandson Mathew Prichard the rights to The Mousetrap as a birthday present when he was a child. Her estate's site says he was nine, in 1952; another source says seven.agathachristie.com and 3 moreJimi Hendrix: Jimi Hendrix (1967) (cropped)1970 · Samarkand Hotel, Notting Hill, LondonJimi Hendrix died with no will, and his father's will later cut his brother out of an $80 million estateShared: 23 years apart; also EuropeJimi Hendrix died in London aged 27; the inquest returned an open verdict. He had no will. His father, Al Hendrix, was his sole heir. The estate was worth about $500,000 in 1970.The Seattle Times and 3 moreGeorge Orwell: George Orwell was the pen name of Eric Arthur Blair (1903 - 1950), an English writer born in British India. On of his first jobs was acting as imperial police office1950 · University College Hospital, LondonGeorge Orwell married Sonia Brownell in a hospital in October 1949 and died in January 1950; his estate's accountant ran his rights until she sued in 1979Shared: 3 years apart; also EuropeGeorge Orwell, 46, married Sonia Brownell, a literary editor about 15 years younger, on 13 October 1949 at University College Hospital, where he was being treated for tuberculosis.washingtonmonthly.com and 3 more