celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Literature and art / Thomas Hardy's heart was buried in his first wife's grave and his ashes in Westminster…
Case file s1850 · Literature and art · 1928
See 1928 on the timelineSee it in 3D
1928
Thomas Hardy: Thomas Hardy Restored Portrait 1910–1915 (3x4 cropped)
Thomas Hardy. Bain News Service, publisher. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
11 January 1928
Place
Max Gate, Dorchester, England
Field
novelist, poet · Literature and writing on the timeline
Legal tradition
English law · Common law
Historical event
The Church of England's debate over burying a known agnostic in Poets' Corner
Member of
American Academy of Arts and Sciences, Royal Society of Literature, Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (Wikidata)
Literature and artBodies, bones and burialsWorld warsEuropeUnited Kingdom

Thomas Hardy's heart was buried in his first wife's grave and his ashes in Westminster Abbey after his executor overruled his wish; a legend says a cat ate the heart

Thomas Hardy died at Max Gate just after 9 p.m. on 11 January 1928. He wanted burial at Stinsford, Dorset, in the grave of his first wife, Emma. His executor, Sir Sydney Carlyle Cockerell, insisted on Poets' Corner at Westminster Abbey. The Dean of Westminster received protests that Hardy was not a Christian, and he asked Hardy's local vicar, who said Hardy never took communion but was "at heart a Christian." The compromise was a split. The body was cremated at Woking on 14 January with Sir James Barrie and one other mourner present. The heart was buried in a bronze coffin in Emma's grave under a yew at Stinsford. The ashes were buried in the Abbey on 16 January, with Kipling, Shaw, Housman and the prime minister, Baldwin, among those present. His estate was valued at 95,418 pounds. A legend says the heart was left on a kitchen table and a cat ate part of it, so a pig's heart replaced it. The story is unproven and no one has checked the grave†.

What the law took from it

An executor's choice can override a written burial wish, so the wish should name who decides.

Sources
  1. archive.spectator.co.ukGovernment record
  2. hardysociety.orgPress
  3. swanage.newsPress
  4. westminster-abbey.orgPress

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Thomas Hardy's heart was buried in his first wife's grave and his ashes in Westminster Abbey after his executor overruled his wish; a legend says a cat ate the heart,” story s1850, https://www.celebrity.estate/thomas-hardy-1928, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

D. H. Lawrence: D H Lawrence passport photograph1930 · Vence, FranceD. H. Lawrence was exhumed in France in 1935 and cremated for a New Mexico shrine, and a scholar reported that the man who carried the ashes said he threw them awayShared: bodies, bones and burials; also Literature and art; 2 years apart; also EuropeD. H. Lawrence died of tuberculosis in Vence on 2 March 1930 and was buried in the Vence cemetery two days later.dhlawrenceranch.unm.edu and 2 moreÉmile Zola: Nadar (atelier de) - Emile Zola, 13-5565351902 · Paris, FranceA 1953 newspaper said a chimney sweep blocked Émile Zola's flue in 1902, and the Panthéon ceremony for his remains ended with a gunman wounding DreyfusShared: bodies, bones and burials; also Literature and art; 26 years apart; also EuropeÉmile Zola died in his Paris apartment on 29 September 1902, aged 62, of carbon monoxide from a chimney that was not drawing. The death was ruled accidental.historytoday.com and 3 moreFederico García Lorca: Lorca (1914)1936 · Alfacar, near Granada, SpainFederico García Lorca was shot with three other men in August 1936, and a 2009 dig at the supposed grave in Alfacar found no remainsShared: bodies, bones and burials; also Literature and art; 8 years apart; also EuropeFederico García Lorca was 38 when he was shot at dawn on 18 August 1936, at the start of the Spanish Civil War.foroporlamemoria.info and 4 moreRobert Walser: Robert Walser, in Zürich, around 1900.1956 · Herisau, SwitzerlandRobert Walser was found dead in the snow in 1956 after 23 years in an asylum, and his guardian Carl Seelig controlled the microscripts until 1962Shared: bodies, bones and burials; also Literature and art; 28 years apart; also EuropeRobert Walser entered the Herisau asylum in 1933 under a diagnosis of schizophrenia. On 25 December 1956 children found his body in the snow on one of his long walks. He was 78.vqronline.org and 4 moreIlia Chavchavadze: Ilia Tchavtchavadze1907 · Road from Tbilisi to Saguramo, near Mtskheta, GeorgiaIlia Chavchavadze was shot dead on the road to his Saguramo estate in 1907, and the Georgian church made him a saint in 1987Shared: bodies, bones and burials; also Literature and art; 21 years apart; also EuropeChavchavadze, a Georgian poet and public figure, was killed on the road from Tbilisi to his estate at Saguramo. Wikipedia and OrthodoxWiki date the killing to 28 August 1907; the Orthodox Church in America says 30 August.oca.org and 3 moreF. Scott Fitzgerald: Photo portrait of writer F. Scott Fitzgerald used in a year-long print advertising campaign for the Woodbury Soap Company, in which Fitzgerald featured as one 1940 · Los Angeles, CaliforniaF. Scott Fitzgerald left an estate of about $35,000 in 1940, and the Catholic church refused his burial plot until his daughter petitioned in 1975Shared: bodies, bones and burials; also Literature and art; 12 years apartF. Scott Fitzgerald died of a heart attack in Los Angeles on 21 December 1940, aged 44. Gatsby had sold fewer than 23,000 copies by the end of 1925, and his book royalties were $80 in 1936.blogs.library.duke.edu and 3 more

Where this case sits

Literature and artBodies, bones and burialsWorld warsEuropeCommon lawUnited Kingdom