celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / War and property / British and French troops looted the Summer Palace in 1860; Yves Saint Laurent's estate…
Case file s1229 · War and property · 2008
2008
Yves Saint Laurent: Graphite and Egg Tempera on Canvas
Yves Saint Laurent. Reginald gray. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
1 June 2008 (Yves Saint Laurent)
Place
Beijing, China; Paris, France
Field
imperial art; fashion designer's estate · Visual art and architecture on the timeline
Legal tradition
French property law; Chinese restitution claims (failed Paris suit, 2009) · Civil law · Chinese and East Asian law
Historical event
Second Opium War; burning of the Yuanmingyuan, October 1860
Religion
Yves Saint Laurent (designer): Catholic (recorded as 20th-century Roman Catholics, French Roman Catholics, LGBTQ Roman Catholics on Wikipedia)

British and French troops looted the Summer Palace in 1860; Yves Saint Laurent's estate auctioned two of its bronze heads, and the winning bidder refused to pay

Twelve bronze animal heads of the Chinese zodiac spouted water from a fountain in the European section of the Yuanmingyuan, the Qing emperors' garden palace outside Beijing. The Jesuit Giuseppe Castiglione designed them. In September 1860 Qing officials seized about a dozen British and allied envoys and soldiers and tortured them; several died, including The Times correspondent Thomas Bowlby. British and French troops looted the palace. On 18 October 1860 Lord Elgin had British troops set it on fire, and it burned for two days. The heads scattered. Yves Saint Laurent and Pierre Bergé owned the rat and the rabbit. After Saint Laurent died, Christie's Paris sold their collection, and on 25 February 2009 an anonymous bidder took both heads for 31.4 million euros. A Chinese association had sued in Paris to stop the sale and lost. Bergé said he would return them if China gave human rights to Tibet and welcomed the Dalai Lama. The winning bidder, Cai Mingchao, an adviser to China's National Treasures Fund, then announced he would not pay. Bergé kept the heads. The Pinault family bought them and donated them to China on 28 June 2013; they are in the National Museum of China. Stanley Ho bought the horse head in 2007 and gave it to the state in 2019. On 1 December 2020 it became the first head returned to the palace grounds. Seven heads are in China. The dragon, snake, sheep, rooster and dog were unlocated in 2011.

What the law took from it

An estate that holds loot can sell it, but it cannot make a buyer pay or a claimant stop.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “British and French troops looted the Summer Palace in 1860; Yves Saint Laurent's estate auctioned two of its bronze heads, and the winning bidder refused to pay,” story s1229, https://www.celebrity.estate/summer-palace-bronze-heads-2008, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Yves Saint Laurent: Graphite and Egg Tempera on Canvas2008 · Paris, FranceYves Saint Laurent signed a civil union days before he died, and his collection sale included two bronze heads looted from Beijing in 1860Shared: the same person; fortunes from conquest and slavery; the same year; also EuropeYves Saint Laurent and Pierre Bergé founded his couture house and were partners for 50 years. Days before Saint Laurent died in Paris on 1 June 2008, aged 71, the two men signed a PACS, a French civil partnership, at his home.lalibre.be and 7 morePatricia Highsmith: Patricia-Highsmith-19621995 · Locarno, SwitzerlandPatricia Highsmith left her whole estate, over $3 million, to the Yaddo artists' colony, and her papers went to the Swiss Literary ArchivesShared: fortunes from conquest and slavery; 13 years apart; also EuropeHighsmith died in a hospital in Locarno in 1995 and left her entire estate to Yaddo, the artists' colony in Saratoga Springs, New York.helveticarchives.ch and 3 moreAI illustration: An empty, broken-open mausoleum by the Wörthersee in Carinthia, 20082006 · Auen, Wörthersee, Carinthia, AustriaThieves stole the coffin of Friedrich Karl Flick, heir to a Nazi-era fortune, from his Austrian mausoleumShared: fortunes from conquest and slavery; 2 years apart; also EuropeFriedrich Flick's companies used an estimated 48,000 forced labourers in the Second World War.sueddeutsche.de and 6 moreCambodge-1223: Les vestiges du Prasat Krachap, un des temples du site de Koh Ker - Cambodge2020 · Bangkok, Thailand; Koh Ker, Cambodia; New York, USAA Bangkok dealer died under US indictment for selling looted Khmer statues, and his daughter gave the 125 pieces she inherited back to CambodiaShared: fortunes from conquest and slavery; 12 years apart; also East AsiaDouglas Latchford lived in Bangkok and was for decades a leading supplier of Cambodian sculpture to Western museums and collectors. He published books on Khmer art and was feted by Cambodian officials.ice.gov and 4 moreAI illustration: Framed and unframed artworks stacked in a Munich flat, 20122014 · MunichA recluse found with 1,406 artworks in his Munich flat left them all to a Swiss museum, and his cousin said he was not of sound mindShared: fortunes from conquest and slavery; 6 years apart; also EuropeCornelius Gurlitt's father, Hildebrand Gurlitt, was a museum director and art dealer who sold Nazi-looted art. Cornelius inherited the collection after his mother died in 1968.Internet Archive and 4 moreGeneral Yamashita Surrenders: General Yamashita, Commander, Japanese forces, ‘Tiger of Malaya,” and his staff walk down the trail to U.S. forces in northern Luzon, occupied by Co ‘1993 · Baguio City, Philippines; Honolulu, Hawaii, USAA Baguio locksmith said Marcos's men seized his golden Buddha, and a Hawaii jury valued the gold he never got back at $22 billionShared: fortunes from conquest and slavery; 15 years apart; also East AsiaRogelio Roxas was a locksmith and treasure hunter in Baguio City. He searched for the "Yamashita treasure", war loot that legend says Japanese troops under General Tomoyuki Yamashita buried in the Philippines in 1945.Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School and 4 more