celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Ghosts and legends / The Tale of the Soga Brothers says a guardian took his ward's estate, the ward killed the…
Case file s1435 · Ghosts and legends · 1176
1176
Soga Brothers Surprising Suketsune, 1890: Dramatic kabuki scene from the famous tale of the Soga Brothers, whose lifelong quest was to avenge the death of their father at the hands
Soga Brothers Surprising Suketsune, 1890. Toyohara Kunichika. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
1176 (killing of Kawazu Sukeyasu)
Place
Itō estate, Izu, and the Fuji hunting grounds, Shizuoka, Japan
Field
a warrior family's estate
Legal tradition
Heian and Kamakura estate (shōen) inheritance; guardianship under a father's will; vendetta
Historical event
Minamoto no Yoritomo's Fuji hunt, May 1193

The Tale of the Soga Brothers says a guardian took his ward's estate, the ward killed the guardian's son, and the son's boys killed him 17 years later

The Soga revenge is recorded history wrapped in legend. The killing in 1193 is in the chronicle Azuma Kagami; the estate quarrel behind it comes mainly from the Manabon text of the Soga monogatari. In that telling, Kudō Suketsune's father died while he was young and named his kinsman Itō Sukechika as guardian. Sukechika married his daughter to the boy. While Suketsune served in Kyoto, Sukechika took the Itō estate, gave the boy nothing, and married the daughter to another man. Suketsune's lawsuits in Kyoto failed; the historian Goza Yūichi notes the text says Sukechika bribed officials. In 1176 Suketsune's men ambushed Sukechika and killed his son Kawazu Sukeyasu instead. Sukeyasu's sons were five and three. On 28 May 1193, during Yoritomo's hunt at the foot of Mount Fuji, the brothers, Soga Sukenari, 22, and Tokimune, 20, killed Suketsune in his lodging. Sukenari was killed that night. Tokimune ran toward Yoritomo and was seized. Yoritomo was inclined to spare him, but after appeals, including from Suketsune's son, Tokimune was executed the next day. Historians since the 1910s have argued over whether others used the attack. Chikamatsu wrote a Soga play in 1683, and the story spread through Noh, puppet theatre and kabuki.

What the law took from it

A guardian named in a will took the ward's estate, and three killings over two generations followed.

Record vs. record

Goza says the estate details come from the Manabon Soga monogatari, and the scholar Sakai Kōichi treats parts of that account as fiction: | The encyclopedias summarised on Kotobank state the seizure of the Itō estate as fact:

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “The Tale of the Soga Brothers says a guardian took his ward's estate, the ward killed the guardian's son, and the son's boys killed him 17 years later,” story s1435, https://www.celebrity.estate/soga-brothers-1176, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Taira no Masakado Kubizuka: 将門塚正面。940 · Otemachi, Chiyoda, Tokyo, Japan (mound); Kanto region, JapanMasakado fought his uncles for land, called himself the new emperor, and his head mound in Tokyo moved the Finance MinistryShared: murder and sudden death; also Ghosts and legends; same era, medieval; also East AsiaKind 1 and kind 2. Taira no Masakado was the son of Taira no Yoshimochi. The Konjaku monogatarishu says his uncles seized lands he was due to inherit from his father. Other accounts give a quarrel over a woman.pinktentacle.com and 2 moreMap of Japan, marked on the globe1986 · Niigata, Sendai, Sapporo, Fukuoka and Tokyo, JapanJapanese courts cancelled auction sales of houses where owners had died by suicide, and in 2021 the state set a three-year disclosure ruleShared: murder and sudden death; also Ghosts and legends; also East AsiaKind 1. Japan calls a property where someone died by suicide or murder a jiko bukken. When courts sell seized homes at auction, buyers have asked to cancel sales of such houses, and courts have ruled both ways.mc-law.jp and 2 moreHimeji Castle Okiku Well: Himeji Castle Okiku Well1741 · Himeji Castle, Hyogo, Japan; Bancho, Edo (Tokyo), JapanOkiku broke one of ten heirloom dishes, was killed and thrown into a well, and Himeji Castle still shows the wellShared: murder and sudden death; also Ghosts and legends; also East AsiaKind 2: what the plays and storytellers say. The first staged version, a puppet play at Osaka's Toyotakeza in 1741, is set at Himeji. Aoyama Tessan, a retainer, plots to take the castle from his lords, the Kotera.edizionicafoscari.it and 2 more230728 Chusonji Hiraizumi Iwate pref Japan01s3: Chūson-ji Konjiki-dō in Hiraizumi, Iwate prefecture, Japan1189 · Hiraizumi, Iwate, JapanThe Ōshū Fujiwara grew rich on northern gold, the fourth lord turned on the fugitive his father told him to protect, his own vassal beheaded him, and his head lies in the family's gold hallShared: murder and sudden death; 13 years apart; also East AsiaThe Ōshū Fujiwara ruled northern Japan from Hiraizumi for four generations. A 2021 study in PLoS ONE says the region exported horses and gold, and its lords used gold to buy influence in the capital.ebi.ac.uk and 2 moreZi Chan: Zi Chan (子產, 子产), also known as Gongsun Qiao (died 522 BC), was the most outstanding statesman of the State of Zheng in ancient China during the Spring and Autumn Period. 543 BCE · Xinzheng, capital of the state of Zheng, Henan, ChinaZheng's minister was killed in the sheep market, his rivals died on the days his ghost named, and Zichan gave his son office to stop the hauntingShared: murder and sudden death; also Ghosts and legends; also East AsiaKind 2: what the Zuo zhuan says. Liang Xiao, called Bo You, was senior minister of Zheng; his family had held power for three generations. He drank through the night in an underground room.zh.wikisource.org and 2 moreStanding Portrait of Emperor Tang Taizong (I): This depicts Emperor Taizong of Tang (唐太宗).626 · Xuanwu Gate, Chang'an (Xi'an), Shaanxi, ChinaLi Shimin killed his two brothers at the Xuanwu Gate, executed their ten sons and had the throne from his father within two monthsShared: murder and sudden death; same era, medieval; also East AsiaLi Yuan founded the Tang dynasty in 618 as Emperor Gaozu. His eldest son, Li Jiancheng, was crown prince. His second son, Li Shimin, Prince of Qin, had led the main campaigns.zh.wikisource.org and 2 more