celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Cities / California's last Mexican governor signed what he said was a mortgage, the courts called it…
Case file s1546 · Cities · 1894
1894
Governor Pio Pico at age 90: Governor Pio Pico at age 90.
Governor Pio Pico at age 90. C. C. Pierce. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
September 1894
Place
Whittier and Los Angeles, California, USA
Field
Californio ranchos; Pico House hotel · Business and finance on the timeline
Legal tradition
California law of deeds and mortgages; finality of judgments · Common law
Historical event
Loss of Californio rancho land after US rule

California's last Mexican governor signed what he said was a mortgage, the courts called it a sale, and he lost his last ranch at 90

Pío Pico was the last governor of Mexican Alta California and held ranchos across Southern California. In 1862, while covering his brother Andrés's debts, he signed a deed of sale he did not understand for Rancho Santa Margarita y Las Flores; the Marine Corps bought that land in 1942 for Camp Pendleton. He lost Rancho Los Coyotes to Abel Stearns over unpaid loan interest. In 1869 he sold half his San Fernando land to build the Pico House hotel in Los Angeles. His home was El Ranchito, a 20-room adobe on Rancho Paso de Bartolo. In 1883 he took money from Bernard Cohn. Pico could not read English. He said he borrowed $62,000 on a mortgage and repaid $65,000; Cohn said it was a sale. The interpreter, Francisco Johnson, first agreed it was a loan and then testified it was a sale; Pico's lawyers said Cohn had paid him $2,000. A first trial found Pico could recover the land on paying $35,000 more, which he refused. Cohn died in 1889, and his successors won a second trial. In February 1891 the California Supreme Court ruled against Pico, holding that a judgment is not overturned only because it rests on perjured testimony. Pico, nearly 90, was evicted. He died in September 1894 and was buried in an iron tomb at Calvary Cemetery. His remains were moved in 1921 to the Temple family mausoleum. The state bought El Ranchito in 1917 and made it a historic park in 1927.

What the law took from it

A signature on a document the signer cannot read binds him; Pico's own deed outweighed his account of the deal.

Record vs. record

Wikipedia dates the eviction to 1892 and says Cohn carried it out; the Homestead Museum says Cohn died in 1889 and his successors won:

Sources
  1. homesteadmuseum.blogScholarship
  2. pbssocal.orgPress
  3. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “California's last Mexican governor signed what he said was a mortgage, the courts called it a sale, and he lost his last ranch at 90,” story s1546, https://www.celebrity.estate/pio-pico-1894, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

The Shooting of Judge Terry - National Police Gazette 1889-08-31: The Shooting of Judge Terry. Scenes in and about the Lathrop, Cal., depot where Marshal Nagle killed the famous hu1885 · San Francisco, California, USASarah Althea Hill produced a marriage contract and a will from San Francisco's richest man, federal judges ruled them forged, and her husband was shot dead attacking a Supreme Court justiceShared: also Cities; 9 years apart; also North AmericaWilliam Sharon was a US senator and the richest man in San Francisco. He owned the Palace Hotel and the Grand Hotel. In 1880 he began an affair with Sarah Althea Hill, paid her $500 a month and gave her a room at the Grand.Cornell Law School, LII and 2 moreGriffith J. Griffith: Griffith Jenkins Griffith1919 · Los Angeles, California, USAGriffith J. Griffith gave Los Angeles a 3,015-acre park, shot his wife and went to prison, and used his will to build the Griffith ObservatoryShared: also Cities; 25 years apart; also North AmericaGriffith J. Griffith, a Welsh-born mining expert, bought about 4,000 acres of Rancho Los Feliz in 1882. In 1887 he married Tina Mesmer; her property was transferred to him before the wedding.cdcr.ca.gov and 3 morePontalba Buildings-Jackson Square-New Orleans: Pontalba Building1834 · Mont-l'Évêque, France; New Orleans, Louisiana, USAThe heiress to the land around New Orleans's main square was shot four times by her father-in-law over her fortune, survived, and built the Pontalba BuildingsShared: also Cities; same era, industry and empire; also North AmericaAndrés Almonester y Rojas, a notary on the Spanish governing council of New Orleans, acquired the land on both sides of the town square in 1777 and helped pay for the Cabildo, St. Louis Cathedral and the Presbytère.louisianastatemuseum.org and 3 moreSailors' Snug Harbor, Staten Island, New York, Valentine's Manual: Wood engraving of the Sailors' Snug Harbor on Staten Island, New York City1801 · Greenwich Village, Manhattan, and Staten Island, New York CiA sea captain's son willed his Manhattan farm to retired sailors, a Loyalist's son sued as heir to the Supreme Court, and the ground rents housed 1,000 sailorsShared: also Cities; same era, industry and empire; also North AmericaCaptain Thomas Randall made a fortune seizing prizes at sea; some historians call him a privateer. His son Robert Richard Randall held a farm of about 21 acres in what is now Greenwich Village.Cornell Law School, LII and 3 moreMyra Clark Gaines: Myra Clak Gaines1813 · New Orleans, Louisiana, USAMyra Clark Gaines sued for 51 years over her father's lost will and the New Orleans land sold from his estate, and her heirs collected after she diedShared: also Cities; same era, industry and empire; also North AmericaDaniel Clark, a New Orleans merchant, was the first congressman from the Territory of Orleans. He had a daughter, Myra, with Zulime Carrière, who was married to another man when their affair began.hnoc.org and 3 moreMark Twain: Mark Twain by AF Bradley (cropped 2)1910 · Redding, ConnecticutMark Twain fired his secretary Isabel Lyon in 1909 and wrote 429 pages accusing her and her husband, a text kept private until 2015Shared: 16 years apart; also North AmericaIsabel Lyon became Twain's secretary in 1902. After his wife Olivia died in 1904 she moved into his house, paid allowances to his daughters Clara and Jean, and helped supervise the building of Stormfield.lynncullen.com and 1 more