celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Fiction and film / In Knives Out, a novelist leaves everything to his nurse, his grandson frames her so the…
Case file s1460 · Fiction and film · 2019
2019
Ames Mansion Borderland: Ames Mansion, Borderland State Park, Easton, Massachusetts
Ames Mansion Borderland. Marcbela. CC0, Wikimedia Commons.
Published
released 27 November 2019 (film; fiction)
Place
Massachusetts, USA (setting)
Field
a writer's fortune and mansion · Literature and writing on the timeline
Legal tradition
US will law; undue influence; the slayer rule, which bars a killer from inheriting from the victim · Common law
Historical event
Rise of will contests in the United States

Fiction: a film from 2019. The people and the estate in it are invented. It is here as an inheritance fight from popular culture.

In Knives Out, a novelist leaves everything to his nurse, his grandson frames her so the slayer rule will cut her out, and the plan fails

Knives Out is a 2019 mystery film written and directed by Rian Johnson. Harlan Thrombey, an 85-year-old crime novelist, dies the morning after his birthday party at his Massachusetts mansion. His children and grandchildren each have strained ties with him and a motive. His nurse, Marta Cabrera, believes she gave him a fatal overdose of morphine by mixing up his medicines, and Harlan sets up an alibi for her before he dies. At the will reading, the family learns Harlan has left his entire fortune to Marta. They press her to give it up. The detective Benoit Blanc finds that Harlan's grandson Ransom Drysdale swapped the medicine vials so that Marta would kill Harlan without knowing it. Under the slayer rule, a person who kills cannot inherit from the victim, so Marta would lose everything and the family would inherit. Marta escapes the blame, Ransom is arrested, and Marta keeps the house. Estate lawyers from Perkins Coie said slayer statutes are real and vary by state, and that a sudden will in favour of a caregiver is a classic sign of undue influence. They also said real estates have no will readings. The film cost $40 million and earned $312.9 million worldwide.

What the law took from it

A will that cuts out the family for a carer invites both a contest and, in fiction, a frame-up.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “In Knives Out, a novelist leaves everything to his nurse, his grandson frames her so the slayer rule will cut her out, and the plan fails,” story s1460, https://www.celebrity.estate/knives-out-2019, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Hedy Lamarr: Hedy Lamarr publicity photo for the film The Heavenly Body, 19442000 · Casselberry, FloridaHedy Lamarr's adopted son sued in Florida in 2000 over a will that left him nothing from her $3.3 million estateShared: new wives, nurses and girlfriends; 19 years apart; also North AmericaHedy Lamarr died aged 85 at her home in Seminole County, Florida.UPI and 3 morePeter Falk: Peter Falk NBC 1967 You Don't Say! (cropped)2011 · Beverly Hills, CaliforniaPeter Falk's daughter lost a conservatorship fight to his widow and then pushed for a lawShared: new wives, nurses and girlfriends; 8 years apart; also North AmericaPeter Falk played Columbo. He and his first wife, Alyce Mayo, adopted two daughters, Catherine and Jacqueline. In 1977 he married actress Shera Danese. After hip surgery in 2008 he developed dementia.Los Angeles Times and 1 moreGlen Campbell: Glen Campbell 19672017 · Nashville, TennesseeGlen Campbell's wills cut out three of his eight children, and they challenged his capacity after Alzheimer'sShared: new wives, nurses and girlfriends; 2 years apart; also North AmericaGlen Campbell, who sang "Rhinestone Cowboy," was diagnosed with Alzheimer's and died in 2017. His widow, Kimberly, filed a 2006 will naming herself executor. It left the estate to her and five of his eight children.newschannel5.com and 2 moreAnthony Quinn: Anthony Quinn around the 1960s2001 · Boston, MassachusettsAnthony Quinn bought 29 acres on Rhodes in 1960, a Greek court cancelled the sale in 1984, and he died before he was repaidShared: new wives, nurses and girlfriends; 18 years apart; also North AmericaAfter filming on Rhodes, Anthony Quinn bought about 29 acres at Ladiko in 1960 for about £1,500. His lawyer said Queen Frederica and the prime minister endorsed the deal.tovima.com and 4 moreCasey Kasem2014 · St. Anthony's Hospital, Gig Harbor, WashingtonCasey Kasem's wife and children fought over his care until he died, then she took his body to NorwayShared: new wives, nurses and girlfriends; 5 years apart; also North AmericaCasey Kasem, host of "American Top 40", had Lewy body dementia in his last years. His second wife, Jean, and his three children from his first marriage, Kerri, Julie and Mike, fought over his care.abc7.com and 3 moreFred Trump Jr.: Fred Trump Jr. 1966 (cropped)1999 · New Hyde Park, New York, USAFred Trump's grandchildren contested his will in 2000, and Donald Trump and 2 siblings cut off health insurance for them and an ailing babyShared: new wives, nurses and girlfriends; 20 years apart; also North AmericaFred Trump, the father of Donald Trump, died at Long Island Jewish Medical Center on 25 June 1999, aged 93. On 23 March 2000 his grandchildren Mary L.gibsondunn.com and 4 more