celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Ghosts and legends / An Egyptian papyrus says the gods argued for 80 years over whether the dead king Osiris's…
Case file s1431 · Ghosts and legends · 1147 BCE
1147 BCE
Horus and Seth crowning Ramesses III: Statue of Horus and Seth placing the crown of Upper Egypt on the head of Ramesses III. Twentieth Dynasty, early 12th century BC.
Horus and Seth crowning Ramesses III. A. Parrot. CC0, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
c. 1147 BC (date of the papyrus copy; the myth is older)
Place
Deir el-Medina, Thebes (Luxor), Egypt (where the papyrus was kept)
Field
kingship of the gods (myth) · Royalty and nobility on the timeline
Legal tradition
Egyptian royal succession from father to son; a trial before the Ennead of gods · Royal and church law
Historical event
Reign of Ramesses V, Twentieth Dynasty

Legend: this account comes from tradition, an epic or an old chronicle. Records do not prove it happened as told.

An Egyptian papyrus says the gods argued for 80 years over whether the dead king Osiris's throne went to his son Horus or his brother Seth

The Contendings of Horus and Seth is a myth, not a record of events. It fills the first sixteen pages of Papyrus Chester Beatty I, copied around 1147 BC in the reign of Ramesses V and found in 1931. The scholar Marcelo Campagno places it in the archive of a family of scribes at Deir el-Medina. In the story the king Osiris is already dead, killed by his brother Seth. The Ennead, presided over by Atum-Re, must decide whether the royal office goes to Osiris's young son Horus or to Seth, whose main claim is his strength. The case runs for eighty years, and the presiding god favours Seth. Seth rejects every attempt to rule for Horus. The rivals race boats and fight as hippopotami. Isis, Horus's mother, aims a harpoon at Seth and hits her son; Horus cuts off her head. In one trick Isis, disguised as a young woman, tells Seth that a wicked man has wronged her family and threatens her son. Seth says such a man must be punished, and so condemns himself. In one version the goddess Neith rules for Horus and gives Seth the deserts and two foreign goddesses. At last Osiris writes from the underworld demanding that his son succeed him. The Ennead rules for Horus, he is crowned, and the presiding god orders Seth taken prisoner. The papyrus is in the Chester Beatty Library in Dublin.

What the law took from it

A claim based on strength held for eighty years and lost once the dead father's own wishes were put in writing.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “An Egyptian papyrus says the gods argued for 80 years over whether the dead king Osiris's throne went to his son Horus or his brother Seth,” story s1431, https://www.celebrity.estate/horus-and-seth-1147-bc, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

The Murder of Iraj: This folio from Walters manuscript W.602 illustrates the murder of Iraj.Legend · 1010 · Iran (the kingdom of Iran in the epic)The Shahnameh says King Faridun gave Iran to his youngest son, and the two elder sons killed him and sent his head to their fatherShared: murder and sudden death; crowns and succession; also Ghosts and legends; also Middle EastFerdowsi's Shahnameh, finished in 1010, tells this as legend; the king Faridun goes back to the Avestan hero Thraetaona. In Warner's 1905 translation, Faridun, worn with age, divides the world among three sons.Internet Archive and 4 moreItalian: Il Papiro dei Re The so-called “Turin King List”, with a list of kings written on the verso and an administrati: Italian: Il Papiro dei Re The so-called “Turin King List”,Legend · 2180 BCE · Memphis, EgyptHerodotus says Queen Nitocris drowned the men who killed her brother the king at a banquet, and a modern scholar argues she never existedShared: murder and sudden death; crowns and succession; same era, ancient world; also Middle EastHerodotus, writing in the fifth century BC, reports what Egyptian priests told him about their kings. He says one of them was a woman, Nitocris. The Egyptians killed her brother while he was king and gave the kingdom to her.Project Gutenberg and 2 moreNaboth in his Vineyard title QS:P1476,en:"Naboth in his Vineyard "label QS:Len,"Naboth in his Vineyard ": Naboth in his Vineyard title QS:P1476,en:"Naboth in his Vineyard "label QSScripture · 860 BCE · Jezreel, IsraelKings says Naboth refused to sell King Ahab "the inheritance of my fathers," and Queen Jezebel had him and his sons killed for itShared: murder and sudden death; crowns and succession; same era, ancient world; also Middle EastThe first book of Kings says Naboth owned a vineyard beside King Ahab's palace in Jezreel. Ahab offered him a better vineyard or its price in money.mechon-mamre.org and 2 morePapyrus judicial Turin: The complete Judicial Papyrus of Turin, the main source for the events of the Harem conspiracy which led to the assassination of pharaoh Ramesses III of the1157 BCE · Thebes (Luxor), EgyptQueen Tiye plotted to put her son Pentawere on the throne of Ramesses III, and a 2012 CT scan found the king's throat had been cutShared: murder and sudden death; crowns and succession; 10 years apart; also Middle EastRamesses III had appointed an heir, the future Ramesses IV. Tiye, a wife of the king, recruited officials of the royal household and harem to place her own son Pentawere on the throne instead.Internet Archive and 5 morePtolemy VIII Physcon: Head of Ptolemy VIII130 BCE · Alexandria, Egypt, and CyprusPtolemy VIII married his sister Cleopatra II and then her daughter, and when his sister held Alexandria against him he sent her their son's head, hands and feetShared: murder and sudden death; crowns and succession; same era, ancient world; also Middle EastIn 145 BC Ptolemy VIII returned to Alexandria after his brother Ptolemy VI died and married his brother's widow, their sister Cleopatra II.University of Chicago, LacusCurtius and 2 moreArsinoe II: ArsinoeII269 BCE · Cassandreia (Kassandreia, Greece) and Alexandria, EgyptArsinoe II married her half-brother Ptolemy Keraunos to protect her sons, he had two of them killed in her arms, and she then married her full brotherShared: murder and sudden death; crowns and succession; same era, ancient world; also Middle EastPtolemy I passed over his eldest son, Ptolemy Keraunos, son of Eurydice, and around 285 BC made the younger Ptolemy II, son of Berenice, his heir. Keraunos left Egypt.University of Chicago, LacusCurtius and 3 more