celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Native nations and islands / The Bishop Museum lent 83 burial objects to a Hawaiian group for one year, the group sealed…
Case file s676 · Native nations and islands · 1905
1905
Map of Hawaii, marked on the globe
Map of Hawaii. TUBS. CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
1905 (objects removed; the burials are undated)
Place
Kawaihae, Hawaii, USA
Field
funerary objects of aliʻi (chiefs) · Religion on the timeline
Legal tradition
Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (1990) · Common law
Historical event
NAGPRA repatriation disputes in Hawaii

The Bishop Museum lent 83 burial objects to a Hawaiian group for one year, the group sealed them in a cave, and a federal judge jailed its leader until they came out

In 1905 David Forbes, a district judge, took 83 objects from a lava burial cave in Honokoa Gulch, Kawaihae, on Hawaiʻi Island. The Bishop Museum acquired them in 1907. On Saturday 26 February 2000 a museum vice president signed papers lending all 83 to Hui Mālama I Nā Kūpuna O Hawaiʻi Nei, represented by Edward Halealoha Ayau, for one year while repatriation claims were settled. Ayau's group put the objects back in the cave and sealed the entrance with masonry and rebar. Other claimants objected that the museum had handed the objects to one group of several. In May 2003 a NAGPRA review committee called it a flawed repatriation and said the objects should be retrieved. The Royal Hawaiian Academy of Traditional Arts and Abigail Kawānanakoa sued the museum and Hui Mālama. In 2005 U.S. District Judge David Ezra ordered the objects returned to the museum. On 27 December 2005 Ezra held Ayau and three other leaders in contempt for refusing to say where the objects were, and Ayau was jailed with no set term. He spent three weeks in federal detention, then was released to home confinement. By September 2006 the objects were back at the museum, and a 7 December 2006 settlement split the $330,000 recovery cost: $183,333.82 for the museum and $146,667.16 for Hui Mālama. In January 2007 all 83 were reported accounted for, with 14 claimants. I found no published final decision†.

What the law took from it

A loan made to settle a dispute among heirs can become the next dispute.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “The Bishop Museum lent 83 burial objects to a Hawaiian group for one year, the group sealed them in a cave, and a federal judge jailed its leader until they came out,” story s676, https://www.celebrity.estate/forbes-cave-objects-1905, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Minik Wallace: Minik in New York1898 · New York; Pittsburg, New HampshirePeary brought six Inuit to New York in 1897, and the museum faked a funeral and kept Minik's father's skeleton until 1993Shared: bodies, bones and burials; also Native nations and islands; 7 years apart; also North AmericaIn September 1897 Robert Peary brought six Inughuit from northwest Greenland to New York. The American Museum of Natural History studied them, and visitors paid to see them. Peary had promised they could go home within a year.nunatsiaq.com and 3 moreDemasduit: Description: Demasduit (1819)DESCRIPTION: Portrait of Demasduit (Mary March) 1819 watercolour on ivory USE/REPRODUCTION: Copyright: Expired Credit: Library and Archives 1820 · Red Indian Lake, Newfoundland and Labrador, CanadaSettlers seized Demasduit to recover stolen property and killed her husband; their remains sat in Edinburgh until 2020Shared: bodies, bones and burials; also Native nations and islands; same era, industry and empire; also North AmericaIn 1818 Beothuk took property belonging to John Peyton Jr. at the mouth of the Exploits River. Governor Sir Charles Hamilton authorized an expedition to recover it and to make friendly contact.Dictionary of Canadian Biography and 2 moreRudolph Valentino: Rudolph-Valentino-by-Donald-Biddle-Keyes-19221926 · New York City, New YorkRudolph Valentino's will gave his ex-wife $1, and his body went into a borrowed cryptShared: bodies, bones and burials; 21 years apart; also North AmericaRudolph Valentino, born Rodolpho Guglielmi, died on August 23, 1926.Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School and 2 moreBuffalo Bill: Portrait of William F. Cody (aka) "Buffalo Bill"1917 · Denver, ColoradoBuffalo Bill's 1913 will gave everything to Louisa; Denver newspaper owners held his $20,000 debt, and Wyoming has claimed his body since 1917Shared: bodies, bones and burials; 12 years apart; also North AmericaWilliam F. Cody's 1906 will asked for burial on Cedar Mountain, above the town of Cody, Wyoming, which he founded. He changed the will in 1913 after reconciling with his wife Louisa, and she inherited everything.cowboystatedaily.com and 2 moreEAST (FRONT) ELEVATION - Henry M. Flagler Mansion, Whitehall Way, Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, FL: EAST (FRONT) ELEVATION - Henry M. Flagler Mansion, Whitehall Way, Palm Beach, P1917 · Louisville, Kentucky, USAHenry Flagler's widow left $5 million to her new husband in a codicil signed eight days before she died, and her family dug up her bodyShared: bodies, bones and burials; 12 years apart; also North AmericaMary Lily Kenan married Henry Flagler, co-founder of Standard Oil, on 24 August 1901. He died in 1913 and left most of his wealth to her. In late 1916 she married Robert Worth Bingham, a Louisville judge.ebsco.com and 2 moreAdolphus Busch: Adolphus busch21913 · Villa Lilly, Bad Schwalbach, Germany; St. Louis, Missouri, UAdolphus Busch's widow stayed in Germany during World War I, and the US Alien Property Custodian took her share of the brewery until she came homeShared: bodies, bones and burials; 8 years apart; also North AmericaAdolphus Busch, co-founder of Anheuser-Busch, died at Villa Lilly, his estate at Bad Schwalbach in Germany, on 10 October 1913. His estate was valued at up to $60 million. His body was shipped to St. Louis for burial.missourioverthere.org and 3 more