celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Oil and natural resources / Comstock heir Clarence Mackay cut his daughter out of his will for marrying Irving Berlin,…
Case file s1402 · Oil and natural resources · 1938
1938
Anthony Comstock: Anthony Comstock
Anthony Comstock. Photographer unknown; author of book Charles Gallaudet Trumbull. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
12 November 1938 (Clarence Mackay)
Place
New York, New York, USA; Harbor Hill, Roslyn, New York
Field
Comstock silver fortune; Postal Telegraph · Business and finance on the timeline
Legal tradition
New York law of wills · Common law
Historical event
The Big Bonanza of the Comstock Lode, 1873
Member of
New York Society for the Suppression of Vice, Republican Party (Wikidata)

Comstock heir Clarence Mackay cut his daughter out of his will for marrying Irving Berlin, and after her baby died he took her back

In 1873 John Mackay and his partners Fair, Flood and O'Brien opened the Consolidated Virginia mine in Virginia City, Nevada. It produced $61 million. Mackay died in London in 1902 and left most of his estate to his wife and his son, Clarence. Clarence's family lived at Harbor Hill, a 648-acre estate on Long Island. In 1922 his daughter Ellin, 21, met the songwriter Irving Berlin. Clarence objected that Berlin was much older, a widower, in show business and Jewish; Ellin was Catholic. He sent her to Europe. On 4 January 1926 the couple married at New York's City Hall. Clarence had his lawyer redraw his will to leave her out. Reports put her loss at about $9 million to $10 million. Their son, Irving Jr., was born on 1 December 1928 and was found dead in his crib on Christmas Day. Clarence visited them, and father and daughter were reconciled. Clarence sold Postal Telegraph to ITT for shares and got through the Depression by selling art and antiques. He married the singer Anna Case in 1931 and died of cancer on 12 November 1938. A New York Times headline of 8 December 1938 reported that his widow would get $2,050,000 and the city house, and that his three children would share the rest†. Ellin and Irving Berlin were married for more than 60 years, until her death in 1988.

What the law took from it

A will written in anger can be rewritten after a reconciliation, but only while the testator is alive.

Sources
  1. nnbw.comPress
  2. interlude.hkPress
  3. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Comstock heir Clarence Mackay cut his daughter out of his will for marrying Irving Berlin, and after her baby died he took her back,” story s1402, https://www.celebrity.estate/clarence-mackay-1938, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Marilyn Monroe: A glamorous Marilyn Monroe in a red dress, taken for publicity purposes for 1953 film How to Marry a Millionaire.1962 · Brentwood, Los Angeles, California, USAMarilyn Monroe's executor told tax officials she lived in New York, so a court barred her estate's company from claiming California image rightsShared: 24 years apart; also North AmericaMarilyn Monroe signed her will in New York on 14 January 1961, naming her lawyer Aaron Frosch executor. She died in the Brentwood house she had bought for $75,000 six months earlier and was found on 5 August 1962.CourtListener and 8 moreMartin Luther King Jr.: Martin Luther King, Jr. and Lyndon Johnson (cropped)1968 · Memphis, Tennessee, USAMartin Luther King Jr.'s estate sued his daughter in 2014 to take his Nobel medal and Bible for sale, and a judge locked both in a bank boxShared: 30 years apart; also North AmericaMartin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in Memphis, Tennessee, on 4 April 1968. He left no will, and his estate passed to his widow, Coretta Scott King, and their 4 children.law.resource.org and 12 moreJayne Mansfield: Jayne Mansfield (Kiss Them For Me) - Color1967 · U.S. Highway 90 near the Rigolets Bridge, LouisianaJayne Mansfield's estate was appraised at $600,000 in 1967; by 1977 her children found about $500,000 in debts and the estate insolventShared: 29 years apart; also North AmericaJayne Mansfield was killed at about 2:25 a.m. on 29 June 1967 when the car carrying her, her attorney and partner Sam Brody, driver Ronald Harrison and three of her children hit the rear of a tractor-trailer. The children survived.The New York Times and 2 moreLaura Ingalls Wilder: Laura Ingalls Wilder cropped sepia21957 · Mansfield, MissouriLaura Ingalls Wilder left her book royalties to a Missouri library after her daughter's death; the daughter's heir renewed the copyrights, and a 2001 settlement paid the library $875,000Shared: 19 years apart; also North AmericaLaura Ingalls Wilder's will left her daughter, Rose Wilder Lane, the proceeds of her literary estate "during her natural life," with the Wright County library in Mansfield to receive them afterward.The Seattle Times and 2 moreJames Dean: James Dean in Rebel Without a Cause (HQ)1955 · near Cholame, CaliforniaJames Dean died without a will, his father inherited, his wrecked Porsche vanished in 1960, and his estate sued Twitter over @JamesDeanShared: 17 years apart; also North AmericaJames Dean died at 24 when his Porsche 550 Spyder hit another car near Cholame on 30 September 1955. He had made three films and no will.The Seattle Times and 5 moreAlbert Einstein Head: Albert Einstein1955 · Princeton, New Jersey, USAAlbert Einstein's publicity rights ended in 2005, a judge ruled, defeating Hebrew University's suit over a GM ad with his face on a muscled bodyShared: 17 years apart; also North AmericaAlbert Einstein died in Princeton, New Jersey, on 18 April 1955, domiciled in that state.cacd.uscourts.gov and 5 more