celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Science and medicine / Cao Cao had his physician Hua Tuo put to death, and Hua Tuo burned his book of methods in…
Case file s1076 · Science and medicine · 208
208
HuaTuo: Portrait of the physician Hua Tuo from a Qing Dynasty edition of The Romance of the Three Kingdoms.
HuaTuo. Unknown author. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
208 (year inferred from the death of Cao Chong)
Place
Xu (Xuchang), Henan, China
Field
medicine and surgery · Science, medicine and academia on the timeline
Legal tradition
Eastern Han criminal law under Cao Cao's command (death after interrogation, kaojing)
Historical event
Collapse of the Eastern Han dynasty and the rise of Cao Cao

Cao Cao had his physician Hua Tuo put to death, and Hua Tuo burned his book of methods in prison when the jailer would not take it

The Sanguozhi (Records of the Three Kingdoms), written by Chen Shou in the third century, says Hua Tuo came from Qiao in the state of Pei. Cao Cao suffered attacks of head wind, with confusion and dizziness, and Hua Tuo relieved them with needles. Cao Cao kept him at his side. Hua Tuo went home and stayed there, saying his wife was ill. Cao Cao wrote to him several times and ordered the local officials to send him back. He did not come. Cao Cao sent men to check: if the wife was truly ill, Hua Tuo would receive forty measures of small beans and more leave; if he had lied, he would be arrested. He was taken to the prison at Xu and confessed. Xun Yu asked Cao Cao to spare him, saying people's lives depended on his skill. Cao Cao refused. Before his death Hua Tuo offered the jailer a scroll and said it could keep people alive. The jailer feared the law and refused it. Hua Tuo asked for fire and burned it. Later Cao Cao's favourite son, Cao Chong, fell gravely ill. Cao Cao said he regretted killing Hua Tuo, because it had made the boy die. Cao Chong died in 208. The book is lost. The recipe for mafeisan, the anaesthetic credited to Hua Tuo, is lost.

What the law took from it

Knowledge kept in one person and one copy dies with them; Hua Tuo's methods ended in a prison fire.

Record vs. record

The Sanguozhi says Cao Cao had him killed for disobeying the summons: | The 14th-century novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms says Hua Tuo proposed opening Cao Cao's skull and Cao Cao suspected a murder plot: . The Song scholar Ye Mengde (1077 to 1148) called the Hua Tuo biographies mythological:

Sources
  1. zh.wikisource.orgScholarship
  2. museumofhealthcare.caScholarship
  3. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Cao Cao had his physician Hua Tuo put to death, and Hua Tuo burned his book of methods in prison when the jailer would not take it,” story s1076, https://www.celebrity.estate/cao-cao-208, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Ishinpo Nakarai: Ishinpō, Nakarai edition995 · Kyoto and Tokyo, JapanAn emperor gave Japan's oldest medical book to one physician family, and the author's descendants spent centuries trying to get it backShared: burned papers and destroyed work; also Science and medicine; also East AsiaThe court physician Tamba Yasuyori completed the Ishinpō, 30 volumes of medicine, in 984. Most of it quotes Chinese medical books of the Six Dynasties, Sui and Tang periods, many of which are now lost in China.online.bunka.go.jp and 2 moreAlbert Einstein Head: Albert Einstein1955 · Princeton, New Jersey, USAAlbert Einstein's publicity rights ended in 2005, a judge ruled, defeating Hebrew University's suit over a GM ad with his face on a muscled bodyShared: burned papers and destroyed work; also Science and medicineAlbert Einstein died in Princeton, New Jersey, on 18 April 1955, domiciled in that state.cacd.uscourts.gov and 5 moreNikola Tesla: A photograph image of Nikola Tesla (1856-1943) at age 34.1943 · Hotel New Yorker, New York City, USAThe US government sealed Nikola Tesla's papers after he died, his nephew took them to Belgrade, and the church and scientists later fought over his ashesShared: burned papers and destroyed work; also Science and medicineNikola Tesla died alone in Room 3327 of the Hotel New Yorker on 7 January 1943, aged 86. The Office of Alien Property took his property, sealed it and moved it to a Manhattan warehouse, though Tesla was a US citizen.Cornell Law School, LII and 4 moreYukio Mishima: Yukio Mishima, 1955 (cropped 850×950 px)1970 · Ichigaya, TokyoMishima's widow boycotted Paul Schrader's 1985 film, and his children won a copyright suit over his lettersShared: burned papers and destroyed work; also East AsiaYukio Mishima died by seppuku on 25 November 1970, aged 45, after a failed attempt to rouse the Self-Defense Forces at a Tokyo base. He left his wife Yoko, whom he married on 1 June 1958, and two children, Noriko and Iichiro.avclub.com and 2 moreRudolf Diesel: Rudolf Diesel21913 · aboard the steamer Dresden between Antwerp, Belgium, and HarRudolf Diesel vanished from a Channel steamer in 1913 and left his wife a bag of money with papers showing his debtsShared: burned papers and destroyed work; also Science and medicineRudolf Diesel developed his engine at the Maschinenfabrik Augsburg with backing from Krupp. After its success around 1897 he became famous and rich.Smithsonian Magazine and 3 morePortrait of Isaac Newton (1642-1727)label QS:Lde,"Porträt des Isaac Newton (1642-1727)"label QS:Len,"Portrait of Isaac N: Portrait of Isaac Newton (1642-1727)label QS:Lde,"Porträt 1727 · London, EnglandIsaac Newton died without a will, and his heirs held his alchemy and theology papers for 209 years before selling them for £9,000Shared: burned papers and destroyed work; also Science and medicineIsaac Newton died on 31 March 1727, aged 84. He left no will and no instructions for his manuscripts, though he burned some papers in his last weeks. His estate was worth about £30,000, mostly stock and annuities.newtonproject.ox.ac.uk and 2 more