celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Explorers / Bounty mutineers' descendants argued in 2004 that burning the ship in 1790 put Pitcairn…
Case file s62 · Explorers · 1817
1817
Mutiny on the Bounty: The Mutineers turning Lt Bligh and part of the Officers and Crew adrift from His Majesty's Ship the Bounty, 28 April 178
Mutiny on the Bounty. Robert Dodd. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
7 December 1817 (William Bligh)
Place
Bond Street, London · United Kingdom
Field
naval officer, colonial governor · Military on the timeline
Legal tradition
English common law; Pitcairn law under the British Crown · Common law · Royal and church law
Historical event
The Bounty mutiny, 28 April 1789, and the Rum Rebellion, 26 January 1808

Bounty mutineers' descendants argued in 2004 that burning the ship in 1790 put Pitcairn outside British law, and the Privy Council rejected it in 2006

On 28 April 1789 Fletcher Christian took HMAV Bounty and set William Bligh adrift in the ship's launch with 18 loyalists. Bligh sailed 3,618 nautical miles to Timor. The mutineers settled on Pitcairn and burned the ship in 1790. In 1808, as governor of New South Wales, Bligh was arrested by about 400 soldiers of the New South Wales Corps. He died in 1817 with six daughters; his twin sons had died as infants. His New South Wales properties (Copenhagen, Camperdown, Mount Betham, Simpson's Farm and Tyler's Farm) were administered and sold between 1838 and 1846. His tomb is at the Garden Museum in Lambeth. In 2004 seven men on Pitcairn, one third of the island's men, faced 55 sexual-offence charges. The island had 47 people. The defence argued that the mutineers had renounced British citizenship by burning the Bounty, so British law did not apply. The Pitcairn Supreme Court rejected that on 18 April 2004. On 24 October 2004 six men were convicted on 35 charges. They included the mayor, Steve Christian, who says he descends from Fletcher Christian; he received three years. His son Randy received six years. The Privy Council dismissed the sovereignty argument in July 2006, and the final appeals failed on 30 October 2006.

What the law took from it

The mutiny gave the descendants no legal standing outside British law.

Sources
  1. search.sl.nsw.gov.auGovernment record
  2. NBC NewsPress
  3. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia
  4. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia
  5. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Bounty mutineers' descendants argued in 2004 that burning the ship in 1790 put Pitcairn outside British law, and the Privy Council rejected it in 2006,” story s62, https://www.celebrity.estate/bounty-1817, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Westminster Abbey, where the story took place1904 · LondonStanley was refused burial beside Livingstone in Westminster Abbey, and his papers were sold to Belgium in four partsShared: bodies, bones and burials; also Explorers; same era, industry and empire; also EuropeHenry Morton Stanley was baptised John Rowlands at Denbigh in 1841, the illegitimate son of Elizabeth Parry, then 18.africamuseum.be and 6 moreMary Shelley: Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley title QS:P1476,en:"Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley "label QS:Len,"Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley "l1822 · at sea off Viareggio, ItalyShelley's father would fund his widow only if she published no biography, and she kept the remains of his heart in her deskShared: bodies, bones and burials; 5 years apart; also EuropePercy Bysshe Shelley drowned when his sailing boat sank in a storm near Viareggio. His body washed up about ten days later and was cremated on the beach. His father, Sir Timothy Shelley, controlled the family estate.mentalfloss.com and 3 moreFrancisco Goya: Spanish: El pintor Francisco de GoyaPortrait of Francisco de Goyatitle QS:P1476,es:"El pintor Francisco de Goya"label QS1828 · Bordeaux, FranceGoya's grave in Bordeaux was opened in 1888 and his skull was missing; he was reburied in Madrid in 1919 without itShared: bodies, bones and burials; 11 years apart; also EuropeFrancisco de Goya died in Bordeaux on 16 April 1828, aged 82. He was buried in the Grande Chartreuse cemetery in the Muguiro family mausoleum, beside his friend and in-law Martín Miguel de Goicoechea.Smithsonian Magazine and 2 moreMeriwether Lewis: Meriwether Lewis-Charles Willson Peale1809 · Grinder's Stand, Natchez Trace, TennesseeMeriwether Lewis died insolvent with his drafts refused by the War Department, and 198 relatives have not been allowed to exhume his bodyShared: bodies, bones and burials; also Explorers; 8 years apartThree years after the expedition, Meriwether Lewis was governor of Upper Louisiana and owed money. On 16 June 1809 he drew an $81 bill on the Secretary of War, William Eustis.US National Park Service and 7 moreJacques-Louis David: French: Portrait de l'artiste Self-portraittitle QS:P1476,fr:"Portrait de l'artiste "label QS:Lfr,"Portrait de l'artiste1825 · BrusselsFrance refused to take back Jacques-Louis David's body in 1825, so he lies in a Brussels cemetery under an obeliskShared: bodies, bones and burials; 8 years apart; also EuropeJacques-Louis David voted for the execution of Louis XVI in 1793 and later became Napoleon's first painter. After 1815 he lived in exile in Brussels. He died there in December 1825.patrimoine.brussels and 2 moreFriedrich Schiller: Portrait of Friedrich Schillerlabel QS:Len,"Portrait of Friedrich Schiller"label QS:Lfr,"Portrait de Friedrich Schiller"1805 · Weimar, GermanyWeimar buried a skull as Friedrich Schiller's in 1827; DNA tests in 2008 showed it and the skeleton were not hisShared: bodies, bones and burials; 12 years apart; also EuropeSchiller died on 9 May 1805 and was buried three days later in the Kassengewölbe, a common vault in Weimar's Jacobs cemetery.NBC News and 2 more