celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Heirlooms and treasure / Italian fishermen netted a Greek bronze in 1964, Italy's courts acquitted the sellers, and…
Case file s1204 · Heirlooms and treasure · 1964
1964
Statue of a Victorious Youth, front - Getty Museum (77.AB.30): Ancient Greek bronze sculpture in the Getty Villa
Statue of a Victorious Youth, front - Getty Museum (77.AB.30). J. Paul Getty Museum. CC0, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
found 1964
Place
Adriatic Sea off Pedaso and Fano, Italy; Malibu, California, USA
Field
ancient bronze statue
Legal tradition
Italian cultural heritage law and confiscation; European Convention on Human Rights, Article 1 of Protocol 1 · Civil law
Historical event
Italy's campaign to recover antiquities from American museums, 2005 to 2007

Italian fishermen netted a Greek bronze in 1964, Italy's courts acquitted the sellers, and decades later ordered it confiscated from the Getty

In 1964 Italian fishermen pulled a Greek bronze of a victorious young athlete from the Adriatic and brought it to Fano. It was sold on. Men charged with receiving stolen goods were acquitted in 1966, convicted on appeal in 1967, had the conviction quashed in 1968 and were acquitted again on 18 November 1970. The court found no convincing evidence it had been found in Italian waters. On 27 July 1977 the J. Paul Getty Trust bought it for $3,950,000. It has been shown at the Getty Villa in Malibu since March 1978. In 2007 the Getty returned about 40 objects to Italy but kept this one. On 10 February 2010 a judge in Pesaro ordered the statue confiscated "wherever located," and reissued the order on 8 June 2018. On 2 January 2019 Italy's Court of Cassation upheld it, finding the Getty had not done adequate due diligence. The Getty took the case to the European Court of Human Rights. On 2 May 2024 that court found no violation of the Getty's property rights. Italy's culture minister said Italy would seek enforcement through US authorities. The statue is at the Getty Villa.

What the law took from it

A buyer who knows a title is disputed can lose the object decades later.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Italian fishermen netted a Greek bronze in 1964, Italy's courts acquitted the sellers, and decades later ordered it confiscated from the Getty,” story s1204, https://www.celebrity.estate/victorious-youth-getty-1964, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

CodexLeicester: Ghezzi-Coke-Hammer-Gates Kodeks1990 · England; Los Angeles, California, USADeath duties forced an earl's family to sell Leonardo's notebook in 1980, and a widow's niece's lawsuit forced its next owner's museum to sell it againShared: seized by the state; also Heirlooms and treasure; 26 years apart; also North AmericaLeonardo da Vinci filled a notebook with studies of water and the moon in the years after 1508. Thomas Coke, later the first Earl of Leicester, bought it in 1717 and kept it at the family estate.history.com and 2 moreMalcolm Forbes: Malcolmforbessr1990 · New York, USA; Saint Petersburg, RussiaMalcolm Forbes spent 25 years buying the tsars' Fabergé eggs, his family sold all nine to a Russian billionaire before the auction, and the US sanctioned the buyer in 2018Shared: seized by the state; 26 years apart; also North AmericaAlexander III ordered the first imperial Easter egg from Fabergé in 1885 as a gift for his wife. After the October 1917 coup the firm was nationalised and broken up.home.treasury.gov and 5 moreOregon Supreme Court Building circa 1922: Oregon Supreme Court Building in Salem. From: Carey, Charles Henry. (1922). History of Oregon. Pioneer Historical Publishing Co.1962 · Oregon, USA; East GermanyOregon claimed a dead woman's estate because her only heirs lived in East Germany, and the Supreme Court ruled in 1968 that a state cannot run its own Cold War through probateShared: seized by the state; 2 years apart; also North AmericaAn Oregon resident, Pauline Schrader, died without a will in 1962. Her only heirs, including Oswald Zschernig, lived in East Germany.Cornell Law School, LII and 3 moreArno Nadel Fritz Grünbaum: Arno Nadel Fritz Grünbaum1941 · Dachau, Germany; Vienna, Austria; New York, USAFritz Grünbaum died at Dachau owning about 70 Schieles; his heirs won them back in New York, then one heir sued Christie's over the restShared: seized by the state; 23 years apart; also North AmericaFritz Grünbaum, a Vienna cabaret star, owned several hundred artworks, including about 70 by Egon Schiele. In 1938 he and his wife Lilly tried to flee and were caught.paw.princeton.edu and 2 moreUBS Headquarters, Zurich (Ank Kumar, Infosys Limited) 01: UBS Headquarters, Zurich (Ank Kumar, Infosys Limited)1939 · Zurich, Switzerland; Brooklyn, New York, USASwitzerland made bank secrecy a crime in 1934, and the night guard who took bank files from a UBS shredder in 1997 had to seek asylum in the United StatesShared: seized by the state; 25 years apart; also North AmericaSwiss banks long said the 1934 bank secrecy law was written to protect money deposited by Jews persecuted by the Nazis. Historian Sébastien Guex of the University of Lausanne calls that account propaganda.daily.jstor.org and 3 moreMarilyn Monroe: A glamorous Marilyn Monroe in a red dress, taken for publicity purposes for 1953 film How to Marry a Millionaire.1962 · Brentwood, Los Angeles, California, USAMarilyn Monroe's executor told tax officials she lived in New York, so a court barred her estate's company from claiming California image rightsShared: seized by the state; 2 years apart; also North AmericaMarilyn Monroe signed her will in New York on 14 January 1961, naming her lawyer Aaron Frosch executor. She died in the Brentwood house she had bought for $75,000 six months earlier and was found on 5 August 1962.CourtListener and 8 more