celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Literature and art / The Tolkien estate sued New Line for $150 million, saying it had received nothing from…
Case file s250 · Literature and art · 1973
See 1973 on the timelineSee it in 3D
1973
J. R. R. Tolkien: J. R. R. Tolkien, ca. 1925
J. R. R. Tolkien. Unknown photo studio commissioned by Tolkien's students 1925/6 (private communication from. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
2 September 1973
Place
Bournemouth, England
Field
novelist, philologist · Literature and writing on the timeline
Legal tradition
California contract law · Common law
Historical event
The Lord of the Rings film trilogy, 2001 to 2003
Religion
J. R. R. Tolkien: Catholic (recorded as traditionalist Catholicism, Catholicism on Wikidata; 20th-century Roman Catholics, English traditionalist Catholics on Wikipedia)
Member of
Royal Society of Literature (Wikidata)
Literature and artPostwarEuropeUnited Kingdom

The Tolkien estate sued New Line for $150 million, saying it had received nothing from three films that earned billions

Tolkien sold film rights to The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit in 1969, under an agreement with United Artists†. That deal gave the Tolkien Trust 7.5 per cent of gross profits. New Line's three films, released from 2001 to 2003, earned large sums; the complaint estimated nearly $6 billion including merchandise, and another source puts box office at about $2.9 billion. In February 2008† the Tolkien Trust and HarperCollins sued New Line in Los Angeles Superior Court, seeking $150 million and saying they had received no gross-profit payments. They also asked the court to let them end New Line's rights to future Tolkien films, including The Hobbit, and sought punitive damages. In September 2009 the parties settled on confidential terms, clearing the way for The Hobbit films. Christopher Tolkien, the author's son and literary executor, said the trustees regretted that legal action was necessary. Christopher died in 2020†. In 2017 Amazon bought television rights for a reported $250 million†.

What the law took from it

A gross-profit share is only as good as the heirs' power to audit and sue for it.

Sources
  1. awn.comPress
  2. thewrap.comPress
  3. dailyjournal.comPress
  4. file770.comPress

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “The Tolkien estate sued New Line for $150 million, saying it had received nothing from three films that earned billions,” story s250, https://www.celebrity.estate/tolkien-1973, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Agatha Christie: Agatha Christie in Nederland (detectiveschrijfster), bij aankomst op Schiphol me, Bestanddeelnr 916-8898 (cropped)1976 · Wallingford, EnglandAgatha Christie gave her grandson the rights to The Mousetrap as a child, and the company holding her estate was sold three timesShared: also Literature and art; 3 years apart; also EuropeAgatha Christie gave her grandson Mathew Prichard the rights to The Mousetrap as a birthday present when he was a child. Her estate's site says he was nine, in 1952; another source says seven.agathachristie.com and 3 moreGeorge Orwell: George Orwell was the pen name of Eric Arthur Blair (1903 - 1950), an English writer born in British India. On of his first jobs was acting as imperial police office1950 · University College Hospital, LondonGeorge Orwell married Sonia Brownell in a hospital in October 1949 and died in January 1950; his estate's accountant ran his rights until she sued in 1979Shared: also Literature and art; 23 years apart; also EuropeGeorge Orwell, 46, married Sonia Brownell, a literary editor about 15 years younger, on 13 October 1949 at University College Hospital, where he was being treated for tuberculosis.washingtonmonthly.com and 3 morePablo Picasso: Pablo picasso 11973 · Mougins, FrancePicasso died with no will and about 43,000 works, and the French state took its tax in paintingsShared: also Literature and art; the same year; also EuropePicasso died at 91 at Mougins. He left no will. The auctioneer Maurice Rheims counted 1,885 paintings, more than 1,200 sculptures, about 7,000 drawings, 3,222 ceramics and about 30,000 prints.Internet Archive and 3 moreC. S. Lewis: CS Lewis photo on dust jacket1963 · Oxford, EnglandA Lewis scholar says he saved C. S. Lewis's papers from a bonfire; a critic charged in 1988 that the story and an unfinished novel were a hoaxShared: also Literature and art; 10 years apart; also EuropeAfter C. S. Lewis died in 1963, his brother Warren Lewis held his papers.christianitytoday.com and 2 moreSylvia Plath1963 · LondonSylvia Plath died separated but not divorced, so Ted Hughes inherited her work and destroyed her last journalShared: also Literature and art; 10 years apart; also EuropePlath and Hughes separated in October 1962. She died in London in February 1963, aged 30. The inquest found suicide by carbon monoxide poisoning.nybooks.com and 3 moreIan Fleming: Ian Fleming c. 1958 (cropped)1964 · Canterbury, EnglandIan Fleming had two heart attacks during the Thunderball trial, settled, and died nine months laterShared: also Literature and art; 9 years apart; also EuropeFleming worked with the producer Kevin McClory and the screenwriter Jack Whittingham on a Bond film script that was never made. Fleming then published the novel Thunderball in 1961.Wikipedia (English) and 2 more

Where this case sits

Literature and artPostwarEuropeCommon lawUnited Kingdom