celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Money and markets / The IRS valued Samuel Newhouse's newspaper shares at $1.32 billion and sought a $305…
Case file s1285 · Money and markets · 1979
See 1979 on the timelineSee it in 3D
1979
Samuel Newhouse: Undated photo of Samuel Newhouse, business person in the mining industry
Samuel Newhouse. Unknown author. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
29 August 1979
Place
Staten Island, New York, USA
Field
newspapers and magazines (Advance Publications) · Media and publishing on the timeline
Legal tradition
US federal estate tax; Tax Court valuation of closely held stock · Common law
Historical event
Growth of private media groups after 1945
Religion
Samuel Newhouse: Jewish (recorded as 19th-century American Jews on Wikipedia)
Money and marketsSeized by the statePostwarNorth AmericaUnited States

The IRS valued Samuel Newhouse's newspaper shares at $1.32 billion and sought a $305 million fraud penalty, and the Tax Court sided with his sons

Samuel I. Newhouse bought the Staten Island Advance in 1922 and built it into Advance Publications, a private newspaper and magazine company. He died on 29 August 1979. He owned all of Advance's voting Class A and non-voting Class B common stock; other family members owned the preferred stock. His sons, Samuel Jr. (Si) and Donald, the executors, valued the common stock at $178.8 million and his 44.44 percent of Newhouse Broadcasting at $68.3 million. The IRS valued the same shares at $1.32 billion, claimed $609,519,855 in estate tax and added a fraud penalty of $304,759,927. Time reported in 1983 that the IRS accused the sons of tax evasion†. The sons argued that four family members shared ownership and ran the company by consensus, so no buyer would pay the IRS figure. The IRS conceded the fraud penalty. On 28 February 1990 the Tax Court held that a buyer would price in the risk of long litigation between the classes of stock, and that the broadcasting stake carried no control premium. The Boston Globe reported that the judge sided with the sons. Si Newhouse died in 2017. Donald died at 96 in May 2026. Advance is estimated to be worth $8.1 billion, and Forbes puts the family's net worth at about $24 billion.

What the law took from it

Splitting a company into classes of stock held by different relatives cut the taxable value of the founder's shares by more than $1 billion.

Record vs. record

The Boston Globe gives the sons' valuation as $235.6 million; the Tax Court opinion lists the estate's figures as $8,595,000 and $170,181,000 for the Advance stock and $68,300,000 for Newhouse Broadcasting:

bostonglobe.comcase-law.vlex.com
Sources
  1. case-law.vlex.comPress
  2. bostonglobe.comPress
  3. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “The IRS valued Samuel Newhouse's newspaper shares at $1.32 billion and sought a $305 million fraud penalty, and the Tax Court sided with his sons,” story s1285, https://www.celebrity.estate/samuel-newhouse-1979, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Meyerlansky: Meyer Lansky, mugshot of New York Police Departement1983 · Miami Beach, Florida, USA; Herzliya, IsraelThe FBI believed Meyer Lansky had $300 million hidden; he died in Miami with less than $35,000 in the bankShared: seized by the state; also Money and markets; 4 years apart; also North AmericaMeyer Lansky, born in Grodno in 1902, was called the Mob's accountant. He worked with Lucky Luciano and Bugsy Siegel, helped build the Mob's casinos in Las Vegas and Havana, and controlled casinos in the Bahamas and London.themobmuseum.org and 2 moreMap of California, marked on the globe2008 · California, USAA son used his dying mother's power of attorney to move $10 million into a partnership and a charity trust a week before she died, and the Tax Court undid itShared: seized by the state; also Money and markets; 29 years apart; also North AmericaNancy Powell was terminally ill and incapacitated in August 2008. Her son Jeffrey held her power of attorney, which allowed gifts only up to the federal annual exclusion.currentfederaltaxdevelopments.com and 2 moreDowntown Bentonville at Blue Hour: Terry Block Building and Walton 5&10 in downtown Bentonville, Arkansas at blue hour1993 · Washington, D.C., USA (US Tax Court)Audrey Walton put about $200 million of Wal-Mart stock into two trusts reported as gifts worth nothing, and the Tax Court ruled for her against the IRSShared: seized by the state; also Money and markets; 14 years apart; also North AmericaAudrey J. Walton was the former wife of the brother of Wal-Mart founder Sam Walton. In 1990 Congress replaced a trust it had called abusive with the grantor retained annuity trust, or GRAT.irs.gov and 2 more1907 Saint-Gaudens double eagle high relief obverse: Obverse of 1907 high relief Saint-Gaudens double eagle1990 · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USAA jeweller's daughter found ten 1933 gold double eagles in his safe-deposit box, handed them to the Mint to authenticate, and the government kept themShared: seized by the state; also Money and markets; 11 years apart; also North AmericaIn 1933 the Philadelphia Mint struck 445,500 Saint-Gaudens $20 gold pieces. Roosevelt's orders that spring stopped banks paying out gold, and none were issued. By 1937 all were supposed to have been melted.cdn.sanity.io and 3 moreAl Capone: "Scarface" Al Capone is shown here at the Chicago Detective bureau following his arrest on a vagrancy charge as Public Enemy No. 1 in this 8 x 10 black & white origi1947 · Palm Island, Miami Beach, Florida, USA; Chicago, Illinois, UAl Capone went to prison for tax evasion and paid every cent, a live TV search for his vault found nothing, and his family sold his pistol for $860,000Shared: seized by the state; also Money and markets; same era, postwar; also North AmericaThe Treasury Department built the case that ended Al Capone's career. He was convicted of income tax evasion on 18 October 1931.fbi.gov and 3 moreMichael Jackson: Michael Jackson 1983 (3x4 cropped) (contrast)2009 · Los Angeles, California, USAMichael Jackson's estate put its value at $5.1 million, the Tax Court set $111.5 million, and a judge later ordered $625,000 in bonuses returnedShared: seized by the state; 30 years apart; also North AmericaMichael Jackson died on 25 June 2009, aged 50, of acute propofol intoxication; the Los Angeles County coroner ruled it a homicide.abcnews.com and 8 more

Where this case sits

Money and marketsSeized by the statePostwarNorth AmericaCommon lawUnited States