celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Scripture and the ancient world / Sa'd ibn al-Rabi' was killed at Uhud and his brother took everything; his widow brought…
Case file s856 · Scripture and the ancient world · 625
625
Isidor Rabi: II Rabi
Isidor Rabi. Nobel Foundation. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
Sa'd ibn al-Rabi', at the battle of Uhud, 625
Place
Uhud, Medina, Saudi Arabia
Field
family property · Land and agriculture on the timeline
Legal tradition
Islamic law of inheritance (faraid), Koran 4:11 · Islamic law
Historical event
Battle of Uhud

Sa'd ibn al-Rabi' was killed at Uhud and his brother took everything; his widow brought their two daughters to Muhammad, and the Koran's inheritance verse followed

The hadith collections of al-Tirmidhi, Abu Dawud and Ibn Majah record the case. Sa'd ibn al-Rabi' was killed at Uhud. His widow brought their two daughters to Muhammad. She said their uncle had taken all of Sa'd's property and left them nothing, and that they would not be married unless they had money. Muhammad said God would decide. Ibn Kathir's commentary says this was one reason given for the revelation of Koran 4:11. Before Islam, he writes, Arabs gave inheritance to males and not to females. The verse set fixed shares: a son takes twice a daughter's share; two or more daughters share two-thirds; a wife takes an eighth if her husband leaves children. Muhammad sent word to the uncle: give Sa'd's two daughters two-thirds, give their mother one-eighth, and keep what is left. The uncle went from holding everything to holding the remaining five twenty-fourths. Al-Tirmidhi graded the report "hasan sahih"; the site that carries it labels it weak. The verse is still the basis of Islamic inheritance law, which most Muslim-majority states apply to family estates†.

What the law took from it

Fixed shares written into the law took the decision away from the male relative who controlled the property.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Sa'd ibn al-Rabi' was killed at Uhud and his brother took everything; his widow brought their two daughters to Muhammad, and the Koran's inheritance verse followed,” story s856, https://www.celebrity.estate/sad-ibn-al-rabi-625, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Battle of Cunaxa: Battle of Cunaxa401 BCE · Cunaxa, near Babylon, IraqCyrus the Younger's mother argued he was born to a reigning king; his elder brother got the throne, killed him at Cunaxa and cut off his head and handShared: cut out of the will; murder and sudden death; also Scripture and the ancient world; also Middle EastHerodotus says that Darius I's sons quarrelled over the succession before his planned war on Egypt and Athens.perseus.tufts.edu and 4 moreHusayn Mosque, Karbala, Iraq 1765: A drawing of the Imam Husayn Mosque by German explorer Carsten Niebuhr during his travels to the Middle East. He drew this illustration of the Im680 · Karbala, IraqMu'awiya made his son Yazid heir to the caliphate; Muhammad's grandson al-Husayn refused to swear and was killed at Karbala with most of his family's menShared: murder and sudden death; also Scripture and the ancient world; same era, medieval; also Middle EastAl-Husayn was the son of Ali and of Muhammad's daughter Fatima (story 22). The caliph Mu'awiya, founder of the Umayyad dynasty, had made the people swear that his son Yazid would be his heir.Internet Archive and 2 moreAnonymous-The King of Dongdan Goes Forth: The King of Dongdan Goes Forth (東丹王出行圖), scroll, light colors on silk. 146.8 x 77.3 cm. National Palace Museum, Taibei (國立故宮博物院). The pain926 · Zuzhou (Bairin Left Banner, Inner Mongolia), ChinaThe Liao History says Abaoji's widow cut off her right hand and put it in his coffin instead of following him into deathShared: cut out of the will; murder and sudden death; same era, medievalAbaoji founded the Khitan state that became the Liao dynasty.zh.wikisource.org and 2 moreDimebag Darrell: Dimebag at Monsters of Rock 19942004 · Columbus, OhioDimebag Darrell was shot dead on stage with no will; his girlfriend of two decades was left out, later took over his estate's trust, and lost most of its suit against Dean Guitars in 2026Shared: cut out of the will; murder and sudden deathDarrell Abbott was shot on stage at the Alrosa Villa in Columbus during a Damageplan show. He left no will.blabbermouth.net and 4 moreAI illustration: An old car parked on a Chicago street, 1970s1974 · Chicago, IllinoisA court had ordered Sherman Gordon to support his daughter, but Illinois gave his only asset, a $2,500 car, to his parents and siblingsShared: cut out of the will; murder and sudden deathSherman Gordon lived in Chicago with Jessie Trimble and their daughter, Deta Mona, from 1970. On 2 January 1973 an Illinois circuit court found him to be Deta Mona's father and ordered him to pay $15 a week in support.Cornell Law School, LIIBundesverfassungsgericht - Karlsruhe: Bundesverfassungsgericht - Karlsruhe1994 · Cologne court district, North Rhine-Westphalia, GermanyA German mother disinherited the son who attacked her, he killed her a month later, and two courts still awarded him his compulsory shareShared: cut out of the will; murder and sudden deathA widow had two sons. In 1982 her will named one of them sole heir. The other son had a schizophrenic psychosis and lived with her in her house. He attacked her repeatedly.servat.unibe.ch and 3 more