celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Russia and Byzantium / Catherine the Great tried to pass over her son Paul for the throne, and Paul made a law…
Case file s822 · Russia and Byzantium · 1796
1796
Catherine the Great: Portrait of Catherine II of Russia (1729-1796)
Catherine the Great. After Alexander Roslin. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
6 November 1796 (Old Style)
Place
Saint Petersburg, Russia
Field
Russian imperial succession · Royalty and nobility on the timeline
Legal tradition
Peter I's succession law of 1722; Paul I's Act of Succession of 1797
Historical event
Murder of Paul I, March 1801
Religion
Catherine the Great: Eastern Orthodox, Protestant and Anglican (recorded as Lutheranism, Russian Orthodox Church, Eastern Orthodoxy on Wikidata; Converts to Eastern Orthodoxy from Lutheranism on Wikipedia)
Member of
Royal Prussian Academy of Sciences, Accademia delle Arti del Disegno (Wikidata)

Catherine the Great tried to pass over her son Paul for the throne, and Paul made a law that no ruler could choose an heir again

On 5 February 1722 Peter the Great made it law that the ruler could name any successor. Anna confirmed it in 1731 and Peter III in 1761. Catherine II took the throne from her husband, Peter III, in 1762 and kept her son Paul away from power. According to the Brockhaus and Efron encyclopedia, in the last decade of her life she decided to remove Paul from the succession in favour of his son Alexander. She put the plan to her council in 1794. It met opposition and was withdrawn, and she found no support for other routes. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica says she may have left a will giving the crown to Alexander, which Paul was free to destroy "if any such will was ever made." She died on 6 November 1796 and Paul became emperor. On his coronation day, 5 April 1797, he published an act of succession that he and his wife had written in 1788 as heirs. It ended the ruler's right to choose. The crown passed in order of seniority through the male lines; a woman's line could inherit only after every male line had died out. Only an Orthodox Christian could reign. On the night of 11 to 12 March 1801 officers led by General Bennigsen, in a plot organised by Counts Pahlen and Panin, entered Paul's bedroom in the Mikhailovsky Palace and tried to force him to abdicate. He refused, and they killed him. Alexander was in the palace and became emperor.

What the law took from it

A fixed order of inheritance takes away the owner's power to pick an heir, and with it the reason for heirs to fight to be picked.

Record vs. record

The Brockhaus and Efron encyclopedia, published under the monarchy in 1897, says only that Paul "died suddenly" in the Mikhailovsky Palace; the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica says he was struck with a sword, strangled and trampled:

Sources
  1. ru.wikisource.orgScholarship
  2. ru.wikisource.orgScholarship
  3. Wikisource (primary text)Scholarship

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Catherine the Great tried to pass over her son Paul for the throne, and Paul made a law that no ruler could choose an heir again,” story s822, https://www.celebrity.estate/pauline-succession-law-1796, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Ivan VI of Russia: Ivan VI Antonovich (Oranienbaum)1774 · Kholmogory, Arkhangelsk Oblast, Russia; Horsens, DenmarkIvan VI's brothers and sisters were born in prison, held at Kholmogory for 36 years, and sent to Denmark in 1780 on a Russian pensionShared: crowns and succession; also Russia and Byzantium; 22 years apart; also EuropeWhen Elizabeth seized the throne in December 1741, she arrested the infant emperor Ivan VI with his parents, the regent Anna Leopoldovna and Duke Anton Ulrich of Brunswick, and their baby daughter Ekaterina.ru.wikisource.org and 4 moreAlexander III of Russia: Tsar Alexander III c. 18851825 · Taganrog, Russia; crisis in Saint Petersburg, RussiaAlexander I sealed his brother's renunciation of the throne in envelopes, Russia swore allegiance to the wrong heir, and the guards revoltedShared: crowns and succession; also Russia and Byzantium; 29 years apart; also EuropeUnder Paul I's succession law, the heir after Alexander I was his next brother, Grand Duke Constantine, who commanded the army in Poland.ru.wikisource.org and 4 moreArrest of the Queen of Georgia (Geoffroy, 1845)-1: Arrest of Maria, Queen of Georgia, in 1801 (Geoffroy, 1845)1800 · Tbilisi, GeorgiaGeorgia's last king asked Russia for protection, Russia abolished his dynasty, and his heirs were suing each other over the royal name in 2019Shared: crowns and succession; also Russia and Byzantium; 4 years apart; also EuropeIn September 1799 King George XII of Kartli-Kakheti asked Emperor Paul I to take his kingdom under Russian protection. He hoped to keep his royal rank and reign as his ancestors had. George died in 1800.acgs.ug.edu.ge and 5 moreIvan III of Russia: Ivan III of Russia 31509 · Moscow, RussiaIvan III crowned his grandson Dmitry as heir in 1498, then made his son Vasily heir and kept the grandson under guard until he died in 1509Shared: crowns and succession; also Russia and Byzantium; same era, empires and conquest; also EuropeIvan III's eldest son, Ivan the Young, married Elena, daughter of Stephen the Great of Moldavia, on 12 January 1483. Their son Dmitry was born that October.azbyka.ru and 2 moreTvorozhnikov: Vasily Mirovich Standing over the Body of Ivan VI at Schlusselburg Fortress1764 · Shlisselburg Fortress (Oreshek), Leningrad Oblast, RussiaRussia's infant emperor Ivan VI was deposed at 15 months, held prisoner for 23 years, and killed by his guards under standing orders in 1764Shared: crowns and succession; also Russia and Byzantium; same era, empires and conquest; also EuropeEmpress Anna of Russia named her great-nephew Ivan Antonovich her heir by manifesto in October 1740, when he was about eight weeks old. She died days later and the baby was proclaimed emperor, with Duke Biron as regent.Wikisource (primary text) and 3 moreTsarevich Dmitry Ivanovich of Russia (1552–1553): Facial Chronicle - b.21, p. 5051591 · Uglich, Yaroslavl Oblast, RussiaTsarevich Dmitry died at Uglich in 1591, a man using his name took the throne in 1605, and Moscow hanged his widow's small son in 1614Shared: crowns and succession; also Russia and Byzantium; same era, empires and conquest; also EuropeDmitry, son of Ivan IV and Maria Nagaya, was born on 19 October 1582. After Ivan's death he and his mother were sent to Uglich on 24 May 1584. He died there on 15 May 1591, aged 8.Wikisource (primary text) and 5 more