celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Literature and art / Trustees for the family of Mondrian's heir Harry Holtzman sued the Philadelphia Museum of…
Case file s1779 · Literature and art · 2021
See 2021 on the timelineSee it in 3D
2021
Piet Mondrian: Piet Mondriaan
Piet Mondrian. AnonymousUnknown author. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
"living; case filed December 2021 (Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas), removed to US federal court 11 January 2022"
Place
New York (Mondrian died 1944) · United States
Field
painter · Visual art and architecture on the timeline
Legal tradition
US federal law (HEAR Act 2016); Pennsylvania law · Common law
Historical event
Nazi seizure of "degenerate" art, 1937
Member of
Arti et Amicitiae, De Stijl, Abstraction-Création, American Abstract Artists (Wikidata)
Literature and artSeized by the stateNowNorth AmericaUnited States

Trustees for the family of Mondrian's heir Harry Holtzman sued the Philadelphia Museum of Art in December 2021 for a painting the Nazis took from a Hanover museum in 1937, valued at over $100 million

Piet Mondrian died in New York in 1944 and named the artist Harry Holtzman his heir. Holtzman died in 1987. In December 2021 the three trustees of a Holtzman family trust, Jason, Jackie and Madalena McManus Holtzman, sued the Philadelphia Museum of Art for Composition with Blue (1926), a 60 by 60 cm painting. The complaint says Mondrian consigned it in 1927 to Sophie Kuppers, who stored it at the Provinzialmuseum in Hanover. Nazi authorities seized it in 1937 and passed it to dealer Karl Buchholz; his agent Curt Valentin sold it in New York in 1939. Collector A. E. Gallatin acquired it and gave it to the museum in 1952. The complaint puts its value above $100 million and relies on the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act of 2016 for timeliness. The museum said it would defend against what it called a meritless claim and said Holtzman knew of its ownership for about 43 years and never claimed it. The museum removed the case to the US District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania on 11 January 2022. On 7 July 2022 Judge John Milton Younge denied the plaintiffs' motion to send it back to state court. The outcome is not confirmed†.

What the law took from it

An heir who waits decades to claim a work lets the holder argue delay, and limitation statutes can decide a case that history does not.

Sources
  1. govinfo.govCourt record
  2. The Art NewspaperPress
  3. inquirer.comPress

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Trustees for the family of Mondrian's heir Harry Holtzman sued the Philadelphia Museum of Art in December 2021 for a painting the Nazis took from a Hanover museum in 1937, valued at over $100 million,” story s1779, https://www.celebrity.estate/mondrian-2021, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Tom Clancy: Tom Clancy at Burns Library cropped2013 · Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland, USATom Clancy signed a codicil 68 days before he died, and the top court of Maryland ruled 4 to 3 that it freed his widow's family trust from estate taxShared: seized by the state; also Literature and art; 8 years apart; also North AmericaTom Clancy, the thriller writer, was the biggest minority investor in the group that bought the Baltimore Orioles in 1993, and split his stake with his first wife, Wanda, in their 1999 divorce.mdcourts.gov and 3 moreMichael Jackson: Michael Jackson 1983 (3x4 cropped) (contrast)2009 · Los Angeles, California, USAMichael Jackson's estate put its value at $5.1 million, the Tax Court set $111.5 million, and a judge later ordered $625,000 in bonuses returnedShared: seized by the state; 12 years apart; also North AmericaMichael Jackson died on 25 June 2009, aged 50, of acute propofol intoxication; the Los Angeles County coroner ruled it a homicide.abcnews.com and 8 morePrince at Coachella 001: Prince performing at Coachella 2008.2016 · Paisley Park, Chanhassen, Minnesota, USAPrince died without a will, more than 45 people claimed to be his relatives, and his estate took 6 years and a tax court case to divideShared: seized by the state; 5 years apart; also North AmericaPrince was found unresponsive in an elevator at Paisley Park in Chanhassen, Minnesota, on 21 April 2016, aged 57. An autopsy found fentanyl toxicity. He left no will, spouse or children.nbcwashington.com and 16 moreJohnny Carson: Johnny Carson Tonight Show 19652005 · Los Angeles, CaliforniaJohnny Carson's trust gave his foundation $156 million after his death, and no public accounting of his estate has appearedShared: seized by the state; 16 years apart; also North AmericaJohnny Carson died of emphysema in January 2005 at 79. He kept his giving private. His charity, the John W. Carson Foundation, had received about $1 million to $2 million a year from the John W. Carson Trust.thesmokinggun.com and 3 moreScott Weiland: Scott Weiland onstage with a mic--2009-072015 · Bloomington, MinnesotaScott Weiland's 2007 will made his ex-wife executor over his widow, and she spent years settling his tax liens and lawsuitsShared: seized by the state; 6 years apart; also North AmericaScott Weiland died on his tour bus at 48 from an overdose of cocaine, alcohol and MDA. He had a will signed in 2007, the year he divorced Mary Forsberg.lanacion.com.ar and 5 moreJerry Lee Lewis: Jerry Lee Lewis publicity photo, 1950s2022 · Nesbit, MississippiJerry Lee Lewis put his ranch in his manager's name to hide it from the IRS; after he died, a judge ordered his son out and the manager's heirs listed it for $1.6 millionShared: seized by the state; 1 year apart; also North AmericaJerry Lee Lewis died at 87 at the Lewis Ranch, a 30-acre property in Nesbit, south of Memphis.savingcountrymusic.com and 4 more

Where this case sits

Literature and artSeized by the stateNowNorth AmericaCommon lawUnited States