celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / Secret heirs / Karl Wilhelm Naundorff sued the Bourbons as the lost son of Louis XVI, and DNA from the…
Case file s77 · Secret heirs · 1845
1845
Karl Wilhelm Naundorff: Naundorff1
Karl Wilhelm Naundorff. Unknown author. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
10 August 1845
Place
Delft, Netherlands
Field
watchmaker; royal claimant · Royalty and nobility on the timeline
Legal tradition
French civil law · Civil law
Historical event
French Revolution; death of Louis XVII in the Temple prison, 8 June 1795

Karl Wilhelm Naundorff sued the Bourbons as the lost son of Louis XVI, and DNA from the boy's heart ended the claim in 2000

Louis-Charles, son of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette, died in the Temple prison in Paris on 8 June 1795, aged 10. At the autopsy the physician Philippe-Jean Pelletan took his heart. Royalists doubted the death, and after 1814 about 100 men claimed to be him. The most persistent was Karl Wilhelm Naundorff, a Prussian watchmaker, who said another child had been put in his place. On 12 June 1836 he sued Charles X and the Duchess of Angoulême, the dauphin's sister, for his inheritance. Three days later police arrested him, seized his 202-document dossier and expelled him to England. He died at Delft on 10 August 1845. His Dutch death certificate named him Charles-Louis de Bourbon, Duke of Normandy, and his tombstone reads "Here lies Louis XVII, King of France." His descendants used the name de Bourbon, granted in the Netherlands, and petitioned French courts and legislatures through the 19th and 20th centuries, with lawsuits in 1851 and 1874†. René Charles de Bourbon lost a claim in a French court in 1954. In 1998 teams at Leuven and Nantes compared mitochondrial DNA from Naundorff's hair and a humerus with Marie Antoinette's maternal relatives and found no match. In 2000 tests matched the heart Pelletan had kept to that family. On 8 June 2004 the heart was placed in the Basilica of Saint-Denis. In 2026 some descendants still press the claim.

What the law took from it

A claimant without documents can keep a family claim alive for 150 years, and DNA closes it only if both sides accept the samples.

Family version vs. the record

Descendants say the remains tested in 1998 were not Naundorff's ( The Leuven and Nantes teams concluded the remains were not the dauphin's, reported in Le Monde on 5 June 1998 (

Sources
  1. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia
  2. Wikipedia (French)Encyclopedia
  3. Wikipedia (English)Encyclopedia

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Karl Wilhelm Naundorff sued the Bourbons as the lost son of Louis XVI, and DNA from the boy's heart ended the claim in 2000,” story s77, https://www.celebrity.estate/karl-wilhelm-naundorff-1845, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

Johann Adam Weishaupt: Portrait of Adam Weishaupt (1748-1830)1804 · Munich, Germany; Gotha, Germany; Stockholm, Sweden; Berlin, Bavaria banned the Illuminati in 1785 and published their seized papers, and a duke's will sent the rest to Sweden to keep them secretShared: secret children and false heirs; seized by the state; same era, industry and empire; also EuropeAdam Weishaupt founded the Order of the Illuminati at Ingolstadt on 1 May 1776.bitterwinter.org and 4 moreAI illustration: Claimants to the Garrett estate queue to file at Philadelphia City Hall, 1930s1930 · Philadelphia, PennsylvaniaA Philadelphia widow left $17 million and no will, and 26,000 people claimed to be her heirsShared: secret children and false heirs; seized by the state; also Secret heirsHenrietta E. Garrett, born Schaeffer, died intestate as to a residuary estate of over $17,000,000. Nearly 26,000 claims were filed in the Orphans' Court of Philadelphia County by people saying they were her next of kin.Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School and 2 moreJames Smithson: James Smithson title QS:P1476,en:"James Smithson "label QS:Len,"James Smithson "1829 · GenoaA duke's illegitimate son left his fortune to the United States, which used it to found the SmithsonianShared: secret children and false heirs; also Secret heirs; 16 years apart; also EuropeJames Smithson was born in Paris about 1765 as Jacques-Louis Macie, the illegitimate son of Elizabeth Hungerford Keate Macie and Hugh Percy, 1st Duke of Northumberland.siris-sihistory.si.edu and 2 moreHôtel du Grand Orient [de France], rue Cadet [9e arrondissement] : [photographie de presse] / [Agence Rol]: Sujet : Hôtels particuliers -- Paris (France) Paris (France) -- Arrondis1940 · Paris, France; Berlin, Germany; Česká Lípa, Czech Republic; German units emptied the French Masonic headquarters in June 1940, the Red Army took the archives to Moscow, and France got them back in 2001Shared: secret children and false heirs; seized by the state; also EuropeOn 13 June 1940 German special units raided the Paris headquarters of the Grand Orient de France and the Grande Loge de France and shipped tons of archives and rare books to Berlin.gadlu.info and 3 moreOlivia Serres: Engraving of Olivia Serres1834 · LondonA house painter's daughter claimed to be a royal princess, and a jury ruled her proofs forged in 1866 without hearing the Crown's full replyShared: secret children and false heirs; also Secret heirs; 11 years apart; also EuropeOlivia Wilmot was born in Warwick on 3 April 1772, the daughter of a house painter. She married the marine painter John Thomas Serres in 1791 and separated from him in 1804.Wikisource (primary text) and 2 moreLady Jane Douglas: Crop of Portrait-Of-Lady-Jane-Douglas,-Full-Length,-As-A-Shepherdess-Seated-In-A-Landscape1827 · ScotlandLady Jane Douglas said she gave birth to twins in Paris at 50, and the Duke of Hamilton sued to prove her son was a stolen childShared: secret children and false heirs; also Secret heirs; 18 years apart; also EuropeArchibald, 1st Duke of Douglas, had no children. His sister Lady Jane Douglas, born in March 1698, married Colonel John Stewart in secret on 4 August 1746.Wikisource (primary text) and 3 more