celebrity.estateAn EGRET.LAW propertyWorld map3D timeline
Home / European families / Ivan Morozov's great-grandson sued Yale and the Met for a Van Gogh and a Cézanne seized by…
Case file s135 · European families · 1921
1921
Portrait of Ivan Morozov2
Portrait of Ivan Morozov2. Unknown author. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Died
July 1921
Place
Karlsbad (Karlovy Vary), Czechoslovakia
Field
textile industrialist, art collector · Business and finance on the timeline
Legal tradition
Soviet nationalization decrees; US federal law (act of state doctrine) · Common law
Historical event
Russian Revolution and the Bolshevik nationalizations of 1917-1918; Soviet sales of art abroad in the early 1930s

Ivan Morozov's great-grandson sued Yale and the Met for a Van Gogh and a Cézanne seized by the Bolsheviks, and lost both cases

Ivan Morozov, a Moscow industrialist, built a modern art collection that ranked among the finest in Europe. In 1911 he bought Cézanne's Madame Cézanne in the Conservatory. He also owned Van Gogh's The Night Café of 1888. In December 1918 the Bolshevik government decreed his collection state property and paid nothing. Morozov left Russia in 1919 and died in July 1921†. The Soviet state hung The Night Café in its Moscow Museum of Modern Western Art from 1928 and sold it abroad in 1933. That year the American collector Stephen Clark acquired both paintings. Clark died in 1960. His will left The Night Café to Yale, which accessioned it in June 1961, and the Cézanne to the Metropolitan Museum, where he had been a trustee. Pierre Konowaloff became the official heir to Morozov's estate in 2002. In 2008 his wife wrote to Yale, and Yale sued to quiet its title. In 2010 he demanded the Cézanne from the Met and sued when it refused. Both claims failed on the act of state doctrine. The Second Circuit affirmed against him on 18 December 2012 (the Met) and 20 October 2015 (Yale), and the Supreme Court refused to hear him on 17 June 2013 and 28 March 2016. In 2026 The Night Café hangs at the Yale University Art Gallery and the Cézanne at the Met.

What the law took from it

A confiscation by a recognized government of its own citizen's property inside its own territory cannot be reopened in a US court, so the heir inherits a claim no US judge will hear.

Family version vs. the record

Konowaloff pleaded that the 1933 sale was "an act of party, not an act of state", a secret Politburo deal that broke Soviet law. The courts held that US recognition of the Soviet government on 16-17 November 1933 validated its acts from the start, and that a state's taking from its own nationals does not violate international law.

Cite as: celebrity.estate, “Ivan Morozov's great-grandson sued Yale and the Met for a Van Gogh and a Cézanne seized by the Bolsheviks, and lost both cases,” story s135, https://www.celebrity.estate/ivan-morozov-1921, updated 30 October 2026.

Related cases

Each one shares a person, a kind of fight, a subject, a period or a place with this case. The line under each headline says which.

AI illustration: Opencast coal mining dug up to the lawns of Wentworth Woodhouse, Yorkshire, 19471948 · Saint-Bauzile, Ardèche, FranceThe government ordered opencast mining up to Wentworth Woodhouse, and the Fitzwilliam earldom ended in 1979Shared: seized by the state; also European families; 27 years apart; also EuropeWentworth Woodhouse in South Yorkshire has more than 300 rooms and an east front of 618 feet, the longest of any English country house. The Earls Fitzwilliam owned it and the coal under it.wentworthwoodhouse.org.uk and 6 moreJacques Goudstikker: Jacques Goudstikker (1938)1940 · aboard the SS Bodegraven, English ChannelJacques Goudstikker died fleeing the Nazis, Göring took his paintings, and the Netherlands returned 202 of them in 2006Shared: seized by the state; also European families; 19 years apart; also EuropeJacques Goudstikker was a Jewish art dealer in Amsterdam whose firm held more than 1,200 works. On 14 May 1940, as Germany invaded, he fled with his wife Dési and their son on the SS Bodegraven.cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov and 2 moreAI illustration: Český Krumlov Castle, the Schwarzenberg seat taken by Czechoslovakia under a 1947 law1950 · Bordighera, ItalyCzechoslovakia passed a law to take one family's estate, and the Schwarzenberg heirs have lost every claim to it sinceShared: seized by the state; also European families; 29 years apart; also EuropeAdolf Schwarzenberg owned the Hluboká estate in South Bohemia. He opposed the Nazis, and in 1940 they seized the family property. In 1945 the Beneš decrees were applied to it on the ground that he was ethnic German.hrlibrary.umn.edu and 6 moreWilliam Vestey, 1st Baron Vestey: Baron Vestey LCCN20147182891940 · Gerrards Cross, BuckinghamshireThe Vestey meat brothers left Britain over income tax, set up a Paris trust and bought a peerageShared: seized by the state; also European families; 19 years apart; also EuropeWilliam and Edmund Vestey of Liverpool built a chain from Argentine ranches through Blue Star refrigerated ships to 2,365 British butcher shops. Wartime income tax rose, and Lloyd George refused them an exemption.The Gazette and 7 moreVladimir Lenin: Lenin in 1920 (cropped)1936 · ParisLenin's 1918 decree took Sergei Shchukin's 258 paintings, and his heirs' claims in Paris and Los Angeles failedShared: seized by the state; also European families; 15 years apart; also EuropeSergei Shchukin, a Moscow textile merchant, hung 258 paintings in his mansion, including works by Matisse and Picasso. He emigrated in August 1918.kommersant.ru and 6 moreWerner Herzog: Werner Herzog-92901934 · HungaryHungary seized Baron Herzog's collection of 2,000 artworks in 1944, and US courts ended his heirs' 15-year lawsuit in 2026Shared: seized by the state; also European families; 13 years apart; also EuropeBaron Mór Lipót Herzog assembled more than 2,000 paintings, sculptures and objects, the largest private collection in Hungary, with works by El Greco, Velázquez, Renoir and Monet.CourtListener and 5 more